Saturday, May 28, 2005

Chippewa or Ojibwe

Within the Wikimedia projects we have some rules. One of them is "ignore all rules" but that is a different story. The rule about what languages we support is based on a few things. For me the existence of a ISO-639 code is the more important one. I have been "bold" as I use the ISO-639-3 code; this one is not even ratified yet but it does include many more languages ..

Today I was working on some translations from the English Wiktionary and the word "fruit" had two translations in language I had not seen before. One of these was the "Ojibwe" language. There is not mention of this language in the ISO-639-3 so I had a problem. The language codes that indicate that a word is a language are based on this code.

Google as so often turned out to be my friend; the Ojibwe are better known as the Chippewa; the code for the Chippewa language is ciw. So I was pleased to have a code to go with the Ojibwe language.

In the Ultimate Wiktionary there will be no reliance on the existence of an ISO 639 code. We could have more languages and nobody would realise ..

Thanks,
GerardM

Wednesday, May 25, 2005

babel

"babel" is a template used on several Wikimedia projects. It intends to inform about the language skills of a person. I am not a particularly good at languages I only care to post about three languages on my user page. The rating is funny because you rate yourself; I do not think much of my German skills, Sabine thinks I should be a de-2 .. She is a "profi" at this language :)

What a template like this can be used for, is not only indicate who has some expertise in some language but also to use it as a filter on the recent changes in an Ultimate Wiktionary. This could function in a same way as it would work for the inclusion/exclusion of bots.

Another use would be to help indicate who shares knowledge of a language, this in turn could help form a community for a language.. I can appreciate that there could be a need for a "village well" or a "kroeg" for each community.

One thing I did find was that it is also a bit of information where you need LOADSA localisation.. There are three templates for each language; Oscar one of my Dutch Wikipedia friends is a tr-3 there is no template for that yet. His being only a tr-3 means that you cannot expect him to write this template in Turkish :)

Thanks,
GerardM

Friday, May 20, 2005

Licensing and mirrors

Most of the Wikimedia projects are licensed with the GNU-FDL license. It works relatively well for server content. There are many people who have issues with it, but given its rules and regulations the content is free and will forever be free. That is genuinly cool.

As I recently explained we do want to use the data in Ultimate Wiktionary for non server purposes as well. I mentioned the .dict data format. Data in this format is also used in off line usage. To create this data you create a subset of the data we hold. Given the license we should inform about every contributor to each word. This is not practical. It is practical to refer to the UW for the history of every word.

As the Ultimate Wiktionary is a new database, it is best to start with an appropriate license that is free and prevents the data from becoming unfree.

With the UW containing the free data, it does not pay to be too concerned about mirrors that host UW data. Given time and the entheausiasm of our community, the UW content will grow and therfore has the potential to outcompete this type of competition in all important ways.

Thanks,
GerardM

Monday, May 16, 2005

RFC 2229 and dict

One of the important things for an open content project is cooperation. Currently every Wiktionary has its own community and, when Ultimate Wiktionary will become a reality, we hope that many wiktionarians will find there home in the Ultimate Wiktionary.

The biggest challenge however will be to grow both the content and the community. As there still a limited number of languages present, we do need to grow a presence, a community for the missing languages. For many languages including my own mother tongue, there is no comprehensive coverage yet. We will be searching for content to be added by our community and by incorporating existing glossaries, wordlists and thesauri.

Today I learned about a third way of making free content available, it is by use of the RFC 2229 a protocol to provide people dictionary information over the Internet. The trick here is that there is a database and that it does provide the information where it is available. So from a user point of view it would be great when we cooperate with dict.org.

There will be two issues that need to be resolved. We use the GNU-FDL license for our content and the GPL for our software and they use the GPL. In order to cooperate we will need to work something out. Licenses are a necessary evil but it would be a travesty if free licenses are found to be mutually exclusive.

RFC 2229 compliance would be for Ultimate Wiktionary mark II .. It is funny that Ultimate will be as much a work in progress as everything else.. Not really a suprise. :)

Thanks,
GerardM

Thursday, May 12, 2005

Ziekenhuis.nl again

Yesterday I mentioned that we received this big body of work of nl-en nl description medical wordlist. People downloaded this list. A Portugese guy who is active on the Portugese Wiktionary has started translating words into Portugese. He found some potential errors as well; what is a diuretic, "diurese" or a "diureticum" ??

More than 18 people downloaded the file already. This is extroadinary when you consider that it was posted on an Italian list for translators.. :)

I understand that some work may be done to translate the list into German.. Is free content not exciting to watch? With these effects I am convinced that we are growing a community that will make the Ultimate Wiktionary a success. :)

Thanks,
GerardM

Wednesday, May 11, 2005

Ziekenhuis.nl

Ultimate wiktionary will get its prominence partly because of what it aims to do and partly because we will actively look for glossaries and coherent bodies of work. The theory is that the whole is more than the sum of the parts..

Ziekenhuis.nl has a 1834 words glossary with academic medical words with a description and an English translation. I received permission to use this in Wiktionary and it is a perfect addition to the EU thesaurus with medical terminology. They will both be included in the UW.

The Ziekenhuis.nl words will be included in the Dutch wiktionary. I have a few reasons to do it, one is my sister teaches nursing and it is nice for her to have it. Another is, that I want to create some buzz about wiktionary and UW and finally as I aim to have words pronounced, I might as well start with it.

As these words are now available under the GNU-FDL, Sabine also mentioned this on some mailinglists and made the file available for download. It would be stellar if this resulted in some translations ..

Thanks,
GerardM

Sunday, May 08, 2005

It is lonely at the head of a curve

Call it hubris, but I am making a difference in the wiktionary world. I have made it possible for programming on the Ultimate Wiktionary to start. I got into contact with GEMET and it may result into something great. I will be the first to acknowledge that it is something whose time had come and that what I have done would not have been possible without the inspriration from people like Sabine Cretella.

But it is hard to communicate the vision that we have. Why UW may make a difference. It is hard to communicate what will be included, why UW may gain a big community why it will matter practically what UW becomes.

People complain that I am not forthcoming with information about what is going on. But I am at a loss how to be more open and communicative. The problem is that there are so many seperate groups of people that start to know UW and want to be informed. It is becoming increasingly difficult to be everything to all.

Today I have finally finished and send an article to LISA, it took me two weeks to write because I consider working with them vitally important. The best thing that can happen is when we get a bigger community around UW. It will make it even more difficult but it will not be so much dependent of a few people.

Thanks,
GerardM

Saturday, May 07, 2005

Swear words

When you compile words in a dictionary, at some stage you will be asked the question, what about swear words. My answer would be: why not. If someone insults me, I want to know what is said and, what it means. Another argument is that many resources do not carry swear words and for translators it is hard to find proper translations. So as far as I am concerned, I think we should include them.

As swear words are a rare resource in the lexicological sense of the word, it would enhance the Wiktionary. When we combine several relevant collections, the total is more than the sum of the parts..

One question I have no answer to, yet, a word like "godverdomme" of god damn me, is only valid in a religious conotation. Should it be in a religious glossary or, should we treat it as we treat categories and have "Christian swearwords" as a subcategory of "Christianity" and "swearwords"??

Thanks,
GerardM

Wednesday, May 04, 2005

Ilse and inspiration

Today I went to Ilsemedia to discuss cooperating on Ultimate Wiktionary.. Ilse is a company focused on the Dutch language market. They want to include lexicological content to the search results that are produced in their search engine. They were looking to implement something themselves but they are interested in cooperating with Wiktionary on this. They produced a mock-up of what it might look like. They are interested in Ultimate Wiktionary because it is free both in software and in content.

We discussed many things about wikimedia, among them Commons.. currently some 90.000 pictures. The problem is finding something. We came up with an interesting idea that helps both Commons and Ultimate Wiktionary.. To motivate you to have a look: it has a nice picture of horses. :)

Thanks,
GerardM

Tuesday, May 03, 2005

New resource found :)

In the Dutch Wikibooks there is a resource that is lexicological by nature. They are words that are foreign to the Dutch language with a description and Dutch equivalents. As the license is the same license as we use in Wiktionary, it is a good candidate for inclusion. It is a glossary in its own right.

Thanks,
GerardM

Monday, May 02, 2005

Windows SP-2

Windows SP-2 is old news. It has been around for quit some time. It is thought to be so important to all Windows XP users that it will become mandatory to have it. There are security patches that insist that SP-2 is installed.

For translators, it is a major pain in the rear-end as the software that they bought will not work with SP-2. Many application either do not have an upgrade path or involve the partition of dineros. The consequence is that these people loose on security or on functionality.

One thing with Wiktionary is that it will be free of charge. It is an Internet phenomena and the only thing it lacks at the moment is cooperation between the different language based communities and content. Isn't it funny that Microsoft's SP-2 is a reason why some translators hope that Ultimate Wiktionary will be a success ??

Thanks,
GerardM

Saturday, April 30, 2005

Kurdish

How do you convince yourself that what you aim for is relevant. Ultimate Wiktionary may become great if it starts to accumulate information that is hard to find elsewhere. I have been talking to Erdal about the Kurdish wiktionary.. He explained to me why the ku:wiktionary would become important; it is the only resource that tries to have all Kurdish words including those of the varieties of Kurdish.

We discussed how this Wiktionary could be integrated into the Ultimate Wiktionary. We will have to work on that but, once it is included, it will be as important as it already is. Combined with the other content it becomes more important as we also aim to have Arabic, Farsi, Turkish, Hebrew ..

Thanks,
GerardM

Friday, April 29, 2005

Koninginnedag

Tomorrow it it "Koniniginnedag", the day when we celebrate the Dutch monarchy. It used to be the birthday of queen Juliana, it was the day when queen Beatrix ascended to the throne and it has always been a national holiday. This year the festivities are special, it is the 25th year of queen Beatrix's reign and as such it is special, a jubilee year.

2005 will be a year with many festivities, we will celebrate this jubilee for a year. The Dutch Wikimedia projects will join Kennisnet in a project to mark the occasion. Wikipedia, Wikinews and Wiktionary have portal pages created in cooperation with Kennisnet's project to celebrate the occasion.

For me, it is one of those rare words that do not translate. I wonder what we will do with words like this in the Ultimate Wiktionary..

Thanks,
GerardM

Monday, April 25, 2005

Spread the word

When you think of religion, it is about the word of God. Religion's words are important to it because they are essential in bringing the message of the Lord to the people. The funny thing is how difficult it is to find these words and its translations. There are now over 50 words in the glossary; many more are missing. Yesterday the new pope was installed, he will have a hard time convincing people if they do not know the words because how can you bring a message if the words you use are not known ?

Thanks,
GerardM

Saturday, April 23, 2005

Nervous for a presentation

Today I will give a presentation in the Molenpoort in Nijmegen about Wikimedia, the projects the organisation etc. It is the first time that I will speak for a big crowd. I am nervous. I showed Sabine the presentation she had something good to say.. I have a long time that I may speak. I wonder how things will go what kind of atmosphere there is..

Anyway, there is nothing more to be done but go there.. I wonder if Jimbo still has this flutter in the tummy.. He does it all the time so at some time it must come natural..

Thanks,
GerardM

Thursday, April 21, 2005

Learning HTML

I do not like HTML but sometimes you are pressed to use it. To add links to other BLOGS, you have to edit the template.. Thank (insert your favourite Deity) for search and replace.. :)

Thanks,
GerardM

Wednesday, April 20, 2005

Larry Sanger on Wiktionary ...

Larry Sanger, one of the founding fathers of Wikipedia, has written a large two part story on /. . In it he describes the early history of Nupedia and Wikipedia in two parts. In part two, he mentions wiktionary and I was really interested in what Larry had to say. I hoped for something profound, something new, something that would inspire me.

For me it was a letdown. Apparently Larry did not have one look at the current wiktionary. When he had typed in wiktionary.org He would have found a portal page for several wiktionaries. He would have known that it is not possible to make a comparison with the likes of Webster's and the OED because wiktionary is not like these pillars of wisdom. Wiktionary is not only about the English language. He would have found many projects in many languages. A bit like Wikipedia but different. Different because if Larry had looked into any of these projects, he would have found that all these projects have the ambition to have all words in all languages. He would have found that current wiktionary has moved far beyond what where the issues at the start.

So it is no suprise that Larry has not learned about the Ultimate Wiktionary. A new ambitious project that may integrate all Wiktionary projects and that will be the first "any to any" dictionary. His arguments against the use of a wiki in relation to dictionaries is a rehash of his POV that you need authority to do some work. If he had done some research, he could have found the soundfiles, something anyone with a "standard" pronounciation can produce. He could have found (with some difficulty) all the Papiamento words in the Dutch Wiktionary, a resource that has (as far as I can find) no equal on the Internet. He could have found that collaboration that exists between Wiktionaries resulting in things like the "Cristianesimo" list of words.

So I am disapointed. As Larry Sanger is a man respected for his contributions in the initial stage of the Wikipedia project, I would be ever so pleased if he had another look. I would really look forward to an opportunity to discuss the opportunies that I foresee in the Ultimate Wiktionary. It would be ever so cool if Larry had a serious look at the current Wiktionary because then we could compare notes on what is wrong with the current crop of Wiktionary projects. It would also make him relevant because what he wrote in slashdot is for me nothing but a blast from the past.

Thanks,
GerardM

Tuesday, April 19, 2005

GCIDE

GCIDE is the website for the GNU dictionary. It is based on the Webster's Revised Unabridged Dictionary Version published 1913. It was supplemented with some of the definitions from WordNet, a semantic network created by the Cognitive Science Department of Princeton University under the direction of Prof. George Miller.

It is a big work, it is published in XML. It is free for everybody to use, licensed under the GNU public license. If there is one complaint to make, it is that it is old and needs updating. Compare it however with the English Wiktionary and you find a dictionary that has other problems that are not adressed. It capitalises every word, many entries are not complete because it does not always state a language, even though it is an English to Any dictionary.

With the Ultimate Wiktionary coming up, at some stage we can choose to either convert the English wiktionary or use GCIDE. The point is that a vocal minority prevents necessary maintenance on the English wiktionary.

The dilemma is: what to do.

Thanks,
GerardM

Monday, April 18, 2005

Shuttleworth Foundation

On the wiki of the Shuttleworth Foundation, I have written about Wiktionary, we would really like to have a rich content of any language, I hope they will apreciate that we do not want South African money, but want a share of the South African languages and culture in our projects and, that we really want the South African people to benefit as much as any other people..

Thanks,
GerardM

The lack of articles on the Italian Wikipedia on the Roman Catholic church

I am working on a glossary with Christian terminology (mainly Roman Catholic terminology). We try to connect to encyclopaedic information in the Dutch or Italian Wikipedia. The funny thing is how little articles there are on the Roman Catholic church in the Italian Wikipedia.

Philosophing why this might be, we can only assume that the church in Italy is a given and that people do not know much about the church or, that it is so much understood to be known that it is thought not necessary to explain it. The result is that it is not possible to give encyclopaedic information to things relating to Christian religion in the Italian Wikipedia.