Showing posts with label Money. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Money. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 13, 2015

#Wikimedia has more #money to achieve more #resultus

The latest fundraiser was a success. It raised all the money needed and then some. The public entrusted us with all this money and the question is now what are we going to do with it all and how.

As a movement we have a mission. This mission is to share in the sum of all knowledge. Our track record is stellar. Never before in history has so little money achieved so much. This is a documented fact; no discussion is needed. We did not achieve our mission fully; no discussion is needed about that either. Wikipedia Zero is just one of our initiatives to achieve more, Kiwix is another.

We are entrusted with all this money. We can put the money to use or put it in a bank. When we are to put in to use, we have to trust that it is spend wisely. The current model is very much one of a benevolent central deity that knows best for all of us. It provides money in a miserly way. It does not trust for the money to be spend wisely; it requires huge amounts of paperwork, reporting. Just as if we are all in business and if business procedures will necessarily produce the best results to achieve our mission.

We have chapters, they are member organisations of Wikimedians. The chapters are accountable to its members. All Wikimedia organisations share the same objective. The chapters are burdened by the requirement of producing reports. Reports that serve little purpose but to satisfy central command. A burden that seriously impacts the effectiveness of the money spend. It is to "prove" that money is spend wisely and effectively.  It results in projects that neatly fit a "best practices" pattern. It does not really allow for experiments, it does seriously hamper potential projects.

It shows how a lack of trust kills us as a movement. It prevents us to use all of our talents, it has us occupied with drudgery.

The alternative is to share the money of this windfall that is the extra money that was raised in the fundraiser with an instruction to the chapters to do good. They can spend it on local projects, on local initiatives. It will certainly be more effective than the current money distribution mechanism. It is not able to cope under the strain of too many requests. Sharing in our excess of wealth will be more effective because in this way more money will be used to achieve our mission.

We should have faith because of our past performance and spend all the money that has been entrusted to us. That is how we shine.
Thanks,
      GerardM

Monday, March 18, 2013

Endowment and #Wikimedia

Every so often, there is talk about an endowment fund for the Wikimedia Foundation. This means that a huge pile of money is kept is reserve for a rainy day.

There are a few problems as far as I am concerned. It makes sense when there is a reasonable fear that we will not be able to fund the projects of the WMF in the future. It assumes all the things the WMF could fund are being funded and are competently managed. The return on investment of putting money in an investment fund .. eh .. endowment fund are better than the return on investment of putting this money to work. People who administer investment funds are bankers.

Given the success of the fundraisers of the WMF, the question if the WMF cannot raise enough funds for its current activities is a joke.

What the WMF currently does and what it could do are two different things. Answering the second can only be answered by looking at what the WMF is there for. I refer to the mission statement on Meta.


The mission of the Wikimedia Foundation is to empower and engage people around the world to collect and develop educational content under a free license or in the public domain, and to disseminate it effectively and globally.
In collaboration with a network of chapters, the Foundation provides the essential infrastructure and an organizational framework for the support and development of multilingual wiki projects and other endeavors which serve this mission. The Foundation will make and keep useful information from its projects available on the Internet free of charge, in perpetuity.


When I look at this text, the last two words can be seen a reason for an endowment.

However, I am certain that we can do more to "empower and engage people around the world". Just consider how much we do in the United States and compare it to Africa, Asia and South America combined. The WMF works in collaboration with a network of chapters.. Most countries do not have a chapter or another organisation .. yet.

Given that realistically the WMF is only investing in Wikipedia, it can not be said that we are doing everything possible to realise the mission statement. It can be argued that we do everything we can manage at this time.

There is enough room for growth and much of it does not need to cost us anything but time and effort. What is needed is the coordination, the planning and the will to go where Wikimedians have not gone before.
Thanks,
      GerardM

PS for an endowment to work well you have to trust and pay a banker. Personally I have more trust in us spending money wisely.

Wednesday, May 02, 2012

#Money for #Wikimedia related projects

Are you passionate about this one idea, this one project that will make a difference in your opinion? Do you know how to run such a project and it is the lack of money that prevents you from executing this plan?

When this description fits you, you should know that the board of the Wikimedia Foundation passed a resolution to create a "Funds Dissemination Committee". The guidelines for this committee are being set up and they want your input.

The cool thing is that there will be a process to get more done and financed. Obviously it needs to arguably be a project that will benefit the Wikimedia movement. At this time you can help define the arguments. This project is run by the Wikimedia Foundation and the Bridgespan Group.

There are two things you can do:
  • Help create a sane funds dissemination process
  • Plan and prepare "must have" projects that need funding and that you can run
What is really interesting is that it will be Wikimedia, not Wikipedia related. This means that all the existing bright ideas about the other projects can be reconsidered. When you are able to sell your idea to this new committee, you may find yourself realising a long held ambition.
Thanks,
      GerardM

Thursday, October 13, 2011

The horror story that is making #payments abroad ...

The #translatewiki.net translation rally ends with the transfer of money. Transferring money is frustrating as often people end up with a pittance because of the costs to transfer money in a worst case (i.e. most expensive) scenario.

The translation rallies should boost the localisation for languages that will benefit the most. Many of these languages are spoken in countries where there is sadly no support by Paypall or where the cost of transferring money is prohibitively expensive.

Paypall does not allow the transfer of money to many countries including Brazil or India. As I have a colleague in India, India is not a real problem anyway. And please, you FIRST have to enable an e-mail account for paypall before can be transfered money to you.

Transferring money by Bank is not easy either. While an IBAN number is absolutely essential, it is probably one of bankings best kept secrets. Learning my own IBAN number was not straightforward at all; why can it not be part of the static information that is part of my internet banking information? It is as if making international payments should be difficult by design. It is as if global contacts are the preserve of companies and criminals only.
Thanks,
       GerardM


Thursday, June 02, 2011

#Wikimedia, get the #GLAM statistics in order

The news letter of the Dutch chapter, has a nice item about the effectiveness of Wikipedia when a GLAM wants to have its material be seen by the world.

The numbers are impressive; the Dutch National Archive let it be known that we are 500 times more effective. The numbers were crunched by Kennisland, a "Dutch think tank seeking social innovation to improve the knowledge society", they produced a report in Dutch that is referred to in the news letter.

The report is quite damning on our statistics. I quote in translation: 
At Wikipedia there is a lack of integrated statistics:
Structural cooperation between Wikimedia and the heritage sector occur with increased frequency. Some small tools have been developed to maintain statistics for specific collections on Wikimedia Commons. What is lacking are running statistics on the Wikimedia servers. This makes it labour intensive to gather data and consequently it is less interesting for cultural heritage institutions to contribute to Wikimedia.
There is more but this is not only a known issue, it is not only an actionable issue, many chapters and the Foundation have enough money; the existing code on the Toolserver did not get reviewed so we do not even have to wait for review. All we need is a developer who is willing and able to do the work.

I have asked a friend with extensive MediaWiki experience for a quote. He promised me a quote by Wednesday. If other developers come up with a plan on how to improve the GLAM statistics, I am happy to learn from them.

When I have a quote, I will be looking for a chapter or somebody to pay for it. That will be next week.
Thanks,
      GerardM

Monday, November 08, 2010

The effect of a $ 100M in advertisement money on the #Wikimedia Foundation

It is an article of faith that #Wikipedia will not host advertisements. Every year there is at least once a discussion that concentrates on the amount of money that we are missing and the effect of advertisement on the NPOV of Wikipedia articles. It is not relevant to ponder the large amount money that adverts may generate if there is no plan what to spend money upon.

Spending money is as difficult as raising money. The Wikimedia Foundation indicated in the past that their growth is such that they do not have the capacity to accommodate such amounts of money at this time.

The infrastructure, the organisation of the WMF will have to change; the role of chapters will become more important and as the chapters mature, they are increasingly able to run the programs and spend the money that will realise the aims of the Wikimedia movement. In order to build the capability to spend,we will invest in our people. At this moment many people are hired through agencies, investing in training will grow our communities and it gives involved people something to aspire to in their Wiki-career.

Wikipedia - T-shirtphoto © 2008 Mike E. Perez | more info(via: Wylio)

Big companies buy start ups. When every year such a large amount of money is available, it is possible not only to develop new functionality. Buying companies like Wylio will quickly provide functionality where we are weak. Functionality that holds us back will be either developed or subsidised because with a larger war chest the arguments why this is not done become even less acceptable.

I [[Edit]] Wikipedia backgroundphoto © 2008 Seth Woodworth | more info(via: Wylio)

Changes in the organisational structure of the WMF will have to take place; the most obvious one is to split the Office in two.One part becomes part of a US chapter and the other part becomes the world wide WMF organisation. This will prevent projects like the public policy project from being controversial. When more money is available, chapters will be trusted to run programs that make sense in their country and projects run in the USA will be evaluated in the same manner as projects run elsewhere.

This central organisation will coordinate and with a yearly budget of $ 100M worldwide there will be Wikimedians who will make it their job to make sure that this money is spend to the best effect.
Thanks,
      GerardM

Monday, March 29, 2010

Musings of a VC in NYC

When a VC in NYC wonders "Does Rest Of World Matter More Than The US?" it is of such an interest that I was plugged in to these musings. On this blog the following ComScore numbers for February 2010 were mentioned.
  • Google: 890mm worldwide visitors, 745mm non US - 84% non US
  • Facebook: 471mm worldwide visitors, 370mm non US - 78% non US
  • Twitter: 74mm worldwide users, 53mm non US - 72% non US
The conclusion is:

The conventional wisdom is that international usage cannot be monetized as well as US traffic and that is certainly true. But with >80% of your potential users outside of the US, I think the web sector needs to start working harder on international monetization.
Even if international traffic could only be monetized 25% as well as US traffic, when your international traffic is 80% of your total traffic, you would make as much money internationally as domestically. So that's a lot of potential out there to be tapped.

The traffic numbers for Wikipedia are not different. This is best expressed in the score card graph.


The Google, Facebook, Twitter numbers are considered for their potential of monetisation. For Wikipedia this is not a stated objective. With Wikipedia the aim is to bring knowledge to every human being. This graph shows where these people are. This graph provides an argument where the Wikimedia Foundation should invest to maximise its return on investmentment.
Thanks,
      GerardM

Tuesday, January 13, 2009

Continued Betawiki activity and info about the EOY prize

The one language that really stood out in the last month was Tagalog. In a really short period of time AnakngAraw did most of what we have to do. As a consequence of his efforts, the MediaWiki 1.14 release will have a full Tagalog localisation.

It is now some time after we ran our Betawiki end of year prize. This effort has been a huge success. Our initial hope was to have some 20 people participate and in the end there were 35. There was some anxiety about continued activity after the event, but as you can see in the diagram we are doing really well.

With so many participants, even 1000 Euro amounts to only 28,57 Euro. For people in Europe, the costs of the money transfer are neglicible but when transferring outside of the EC, mean costs that start with 10 or 18 Euro and, then you may still have to pay premiums. It is for this reason that we are looking for alternative ways of paying money.. Paypal is interesting but it has its restrictions and, it is not available in all countries..
Thanks,
GerardM