Forget #Wikipedia for a moment. #Wikidata does more; it supports #Commons, #Wikivoyage and it will support #Wikisource really soon now. Wikidata adds value particularly when it is used in the context of the Wikis that make use of it.
Many people consider that Wikidata is there to support their Wikipedia. It is equally true that Wikidata is able to support the Wikivoyages. As more projects are supported, the fallacy that Wikidata exist to support a specific wiki becomes even more obvious.
The Wikidata extension to search results reflects nicely the power of Wikidata. It helps with the disambiguation of the items, it indicates if there are Wikipedia and now Wikivoyage articles, you can be directed to Commons to find images and finally it shows what it has to offer by presenting information nicely in the Reasonator.
The news in this blog post is that Wikivoyage features among the results for each item. What is new to most people is that the Wikidata extension to search is not restricted to Wikipedia. It will work equally well on Commons and Wikivoyage .. Wikibooks and Wiktionary.
Thanks,
GerardM
Showing posts with label Wikivoyage. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Wikivoyage. Show all posts
Thursday, January 09, 2014
Wednesday, September 25, 2013
The #Vietnamese #Wikivoyage is joining #Wikidata
The Vietnamese Wikivoyage has been live for some time now and, many of its articles were linked in the classical way to articles in the English Wikivoyage. Thanks to Dexot, all the articles are getting the royal treatment. The old links are deleted and they are linked into Wikidata.
Thanks,
GerardM
Saturday, September 07, 2013
#Wikidata supports 280+ Wikipedias and 10+ Wikivoyages
Every #Wikipedia needs great quality facts. Every Wikipedia faces the challenge of maintaining the facts it has in its articles and in its infoboxes. It is like the Herculean task of cleaning the Augean stables; it never stops and you never know where and when another fact has to be cleaned up. It is even worse, the same fact has the potential to be crappy in 280+ Wikipedias.
With Wikidata there is a new way of making the most of a bad situation. It is still necessary to update facts whenever they change but this change is made at Wikidata. Every project that uses this fact will be updated. Changes go to the recent changes of those projects and to the watch lists that include the articles involved.
There is only one thing needed to make this happen. People need to trust Wikidata and the existing mechanisms to fight abuse. There is no alternative as there are no mechanisms to flag changes in Wikidata where the data in Wikipedia is not served by Wikidata. The most compelling reason to serve data from Wikidata is that we just do not have the capacity to fix by hand all changes everywhere. The fire-hose of changes of facts will prove too much.
Thanks,
GerardM
With Wikidata there is a new way of making the most of a bad situation. It is still necessary to update facts whenever they change but this change is made at Wikidata. Every project that uses this fact will be updated. Changes go to the recent changes of those projects and to the watch lists that include the articles involved.
There is only one thing needed to make this happen. People need to trust Wikidata and the existing mechanisms to fight abuse. There is no alternative as there are no mechanisms to flag changes in Wikidata where the data in Wikipedia is not served by Wikidata. The most compelling reason to serve data from Wikidata is that we just do not have the capacity to fix by hand all changes everywhere. The fire-hose of changes of facts will prove too much.
Thanks,
GerardM
Saturday, August 31, 2013
A #chicken and #egg issue for #Wikidata
Many a #Wikipedia uses bots to generate articles. The same data is often used to create articles or to enrich articles on multiple Wikipedias. When this is first uploaded to Wikidata, there are already Wikipedias that do not need any update. With some clever templates, the information will appear automagically. Only when an item does not have an article, the article needs to be created with an appropriate template. The article needs to be linked to Wikidata for the data to be found.
There are issues with the execution of this model but the most important one is a cultural one; when you work with data to generate stubs, there are benefits to concentrate first on Wikidata. The biggest benefit is that the data is integrated from the start and a close second is the ability to easily use it in another Wikipedia and maybe in Wikivoyage as well.
At this stage of the Wikidata game there are important issues:
You may find that the data already exists in other projects and you are likely to find differences. Finding these issues and curating them is crucial to all of them. The trick is to make sure that this is done only once and, this is where Wikidata shines.
Thanks,
GerardM
There are issues with the execution of this model but the most important one is a cultural one; when you work with data to generate stubs, there are benefits to concentrate first on Wikidata. The biggest benefit is that the data is integrated from the start and a close second is the ability to easily use it in another Wikipedia and maybe in Wikivoyage as well.
At this stage of the Wikidata game there are important issues:
- many datatypes are not yet supported
- many datatypes cannot be imported yet with a bot
You may find that the data already exists in other projects and you are likely to find differences. Finding these issues and curating them is crucial to all of them. The trick is to make sure that this is done only once and, this is where Wikidata shines.
Thanks,
GerardM
Thursday, August 22, 2013
The new #Vietnamese #Wikivoyage
Recently a new Wiki was created for the Vietnamese Wikivoyage. At that time the language committee is informed that its process is done because the relevant Bugzilla bug is resolved
Once a project is created, there are always these small details that still have to be sorted out. The most important thing is that the new project can be found in the many places where it should be added. The most obvious one is at Wikivoyage.org another is the statistics page for Wikivoyage. Finally the Vietnamese articles have to become known in Wikidata.
Now that the interwiki links of Wikivoyage are maintained at Wikidata, it is not clear to me when the links are picked up by a bot. I do not have the skills to change the template for the main page of Wikivoyage. The one thing I have done is inform the relevant person to add the Vietnamese Wikivoyage to the statistics page; that is something that takes its time.
At some stage all these things get resolved. It would help if it is part of the process to create a new Wiki.
Thanks,
GerardM
Sunday, April 14, 2013
#Wikivoyage #statistics revisited
I am happy to report that many of the issues with several statistics have been resolved. The most visible improvement is that the page views for Wikivoyage are now available and updated on a daily basis. When you check out these statistics you notice that Wikivoyage got the most attention when it was started. Now in the fourth month we can notice some stabilisation.
The latest Wikivoyage projects in Hebrew and Ukrainian are now included as well and it will be interesting to follow how they will do in the future.
I am really happy that many issues have been resolved. If anything, statistics are trusted because of the consistency and quality of the presentation. When you follow developments regularly you get a feeling for the underlying data. Waiting for the resolution of what seems like cosmetic issues destroys that feeling.
Thanks,
GerardM
Sunday, February 03, 2013
#Wikivoyage #statistics II
The first month of Wikivoyage statistics is in. The page views statistics are now regularly updated. There is now a baseline to compare future months with. Last week I blogged about Wikivoyage statistics and at that time traffic was expected to reach 12.8 M. As you can see in the screen dump, it ended up at 17.3 M.
Over time Wikivoyage will become increasingly Wikivoyage. It will slowly but surely morph into something that can be distinguished from Wikitravel. Once that process is well under way, I am sure that there will be a growing public for this Wikimedia project.
Thanks,
GerardM
Monday, January 28, 2013
#Wikivoyage #statistics
Page views are now also collected for Wikivoyage. At this stage it is indicated that they are page views from non-mobile devices. It is likely that the mobile page views will follow at a later date; Wikivoyage is after all the resource for people who are travelling or are about to travel.
Thanks,
GerardM
Tuesday, November 06, 2012
#Wikivoyage pictures; the fun of being there
The coin dropped for me. Once Wikivoyage is a running Wikimedia project, it is about travelling, going on a holiday, seeing the sites. All these articles need their illustrations. I think that this is to be expected. It is obvious to me what kind of pictures they can be.
Many of them will be holiday pictures and, there is nothing wrong with that. These pictures will have a use, they illustrate Wikivoyage.
What I like about it is that they broaden the horizon of Commons and hopefully inject Commons with many more fun images.
The Commons challenge will only become more relevant; what will it take to make it the wiki where everyone can easily find a great and appropriate media file.
Thanks,
GerardM
Many of them will be holiday pictures and, there is nothing wrong with that. These pictures will have a use, they illustrate Wikivoyage.
What I like about it is that they broaden the horizon of Commons and hopefully inject Commons with many more fun images.
The Commons challenge will only become more relevant; what will it take to make it the wiki where everyone can easily find a great and appropriate media file.
Thanks,
GerardM
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






