Showing posts with label visualisation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label visualisation. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 25, 2014

#Reasonator - eye candy

There is no particular reason why I show Mr Trent to good effect. It is just that Reasonator makes him look good.
Thanks,
    Gerard

Monday, November 18, 2013

#Ask and it will be #given to you II

Sharing in the sum of all knowledge is the aim of the #Wikimedia Foundation. The challenge is to bring it to all people of this world. Given that its projects are Internet based, it is reasonable to concentrate on the people connected to the Internet.

With one extra line in the USER/common,js it is possible to expand the search by adding results from Wikidata. This has been mentioned before.

What is new is, that it will now include references to articles in Wikipedia and pictures in Commons. Just click on the Commons logo and you go to the Commons category for the subject when it is known in Wikidata. When you click on the Wikipedia logo, you get a box with the Wikis you can choose from.

Really cool is that the Reasonator will provide you information in YOUR language. It is probably the best incentive to add the labels missing for your language. Remember, labels are used everywhere.

Talking about Reasonator, we are looking for a nice logo that we can use...
Thanks,
      GerardM

Friday, November 08, 2013

#divcon - #Search, #statistics and the proof of the pudding

When you search #Wikidata, chances are that you have a better result for your language than in Wikipedia. As the proof of the pudding is in the eating, there are 5,801,862 items with a label in English and, there are 5,319,467 items with a link to Wikipedia. Based on this comparison, there are 482,395 more labels than links.

These numbers are provided yet again by a new tool from Magnus. This is not to say that we cover the sum of all knowledge; Google does a better job at that. What these statistics show is that we have a perspective on doing a better job at providing information.

When we look at people with the Reasonator, you get a glimpse of what can be done with visualisation. It shows the information in an ordered way and it is easy to notice what is missing. When we present you with all the female painters, it does not take much to notice that women from Scandinavia, East Europe or Asia are mostly missing. This is not even to say that the lady painters from the Anglo-Saxon cultures are well covered in Wikidata. It is however exactly the point; this lists motivates to find more lady painters. You are welcome to fiddle with the query to find data out that motivates you.

These tools are a hack; they demonstrate a future that needs to be build for us all to use. As the future gets build, it needs to scale and it needs to be usable in any language. There are so many pieces to that puzzle, the questions are many; what will be build first and, who is going to do all that and when will we be happy.
Thanks,
      GerardM

Monday, October 28, 2013

Abdullah, King of #Saoudi Arabia


King Abdullah has many brothers and sisters. In #Wikidata he and his siblings are registered as children of his father. Different is that the Reasonator now shows them by querying the parents. It is no longer needed to register them as brother or sister on each brother and sister.
Thanks,
      GerardM

Friday, October 18, 2013

Reasonator gets "instance of" "#human"

Reasonator, the tool by Magnus now appreciates that a person is a "human". An increasing number of items in Wikidata identify a person as a human. As a consequence, all the tools that rely on appreciating that an item is about a human need to adapt. When you are aware of tools that still need to adapt, pinging the author of the tool is a reasonable approach :)


I selected Herman Melville for the illustration; he is mentioned today as the author of Moby Dick on the main page of the English language Wikipedia.
Thanks,
         GerardM

Thursday, October 10, 2013

Abdallah II, six times Sultan of #Morocco

When the title of Sultan is supposed to be hereditary, calling the title yours six times in a row is special. Abdallah of Morocco had the dubious pleasure to fight his many brothers to finally gain the upper hand.

On the French Wikipedia, they have visualised this nicely. This  information is available on Wikidata using qualifiers. As the use of qualifiers to indicate who preceded and succeeded as Sultan is not universally liked, the question is very much what could serve as an alternative?
Thanks,
      GerardM


Saturday, October 05, 2013

10 #Wikidata questions for Lydia

Lydia is the new project leader for Wikidata. She has already done a great job communicating for the Wikidata project and, with much of Wikidata well established, communication will increasingly be the critical success factor. The Wikidata team works together well so I think she will do really well. Enough reasons to ask her some questions. I hope you will enjoy them as much as her answers.
Thanks,
     GerardM

Wikidata exists, it is being used. Do we know how much it is used?
Unfortunately not. Of course we get to see some great uses but not the whole picture. I love seeing all the different ways the Wikipedias are already now using Wikidata that I know about. For example the Occitan Wikipedia building whole infoboxes based on data from Wikidata. Or the English Wikipedia that compares its local IMDB identifiers against those in Wikidata and puts pages into a maintenance category if they do not match so a human can look into it and fix it. But this is only inside the big Wikimedia projects. At the same time people are building 3rd-party tools that use data from Wikidata. The most recent and very impressive one is the Wikidata tempo-spatial display. We are seeing more and more of these pop up and I am looking forward to what other useful, cool and even crazy things people will come up with.
You want people to trust Wikidata data. How do you envision this to work?
Wikidata has just started and we're seeing people add a lot of data to it for all the world to use. This is fantastic. At the same time we need to make sure that the data in Wikidata is reasonably trustworthy. I say reasonably trustworthy because in the end this is just like Wikipedia. It's not 100% perfect but we're all making a huge effort to keep it as accurate and correct as possible and people have come to rely on this. Wikidata is in a bit of a better situation here though than Wikipedia for a few reasons. First of all since the data is structured and machine-readable it is much easier for a computer to find inconsistencies and alert an editor about them. One example would be that a political office is said to be held by X but X is said to be an animal. Now there were probably a few cases where a political office was held by an animal but in general things like this should be flagged for an editor to reexamine it. And there are many such cases that could be checked. Here you find a few such checks that are already in place. The other advantage Wikidata has is that it will be much easier to verify a given data point against an external source once that is given in Wikidata. And the third advantage Wikidata has is that it will be watched by potentially a lot more people. Changes in Wikidata show up on the watchlists of all editors who are watching the corresponding page on their Wikipedia as well as the recent changes of that Wikipedia. So all in all we are in a pretty good position. However we are not there yet. More tools will need to be developed, existing ones improved and most importantly people will need to spend time adding sources to statements in Wikidata.
When you talk about the user experience of Wikidata, what are the limits of this user experience as far as you are involved?
I want Wikidata to be a joy to use and I want it to be easy to use. At the same time experienced editors need to be able to navigate the site and complete their tasks quickly and efficiently. We will have to find the right balance there over and over again. The same thing goes for all the missing features we still have to develop or roll out - queries and the numbers datatype for example. I will put more emphasis on user experience but moving the project forward on a feature level is also very important.
One obvious target for Wikidata is to include all the information contained in info boxes. How far off are we before Wikidata can service most subjects that have info boxes.
I think the big missing piece of the puzzle is the numbers datatype. We're not too far from rolling out a first version of it. Once we are able to also deal with units we are well on our way to that target.
You want people to better understand Wikidata. Is that not even more complicated than understanding templates and info-boxes?
They should absolutely not need to understand everything about Wikidata. This would not work. But for those who interact with Wikidata regularly it should be easy to understand what is going on - not in detail but the bigger picture. To get there we need to improve a few things in the user interface but we will also need to adapt our help pages to be less technical.
What can people do to make Wikidata be useful in their language
Wikidata is inherently a multilingual project. It allows you to use the site in your language and will show you the data it has in your language. Have a look at for example item Q2 in German, English and Spanish. To be able to do this Wikidata needs to know the names of all these things in the different languages. That's what we call "labels". These labels are really important in all kinds of places in Wikidata as they make it possible to refer to things by their name instead of the identifier we gave it - Q2 in the example above. So the best way to make Wikidata more useful in a language is to enter a lot of labels and descriptions in that language. The Special Pages Entities without Label  and Entities without Description are there to help with this as well as the Terminator tool that sorts them by how often they are used to increase effectiveness. This is especially important for the smaller languages. If you speak several languages you should also add a babel box to your user page on Wikidata like I have done on mine. Once Wikidata knows which languages you are speaking this way it will show you the labels and descriptions for a given thing in these languages as well and will let you complete them in case they are still missing. Over time Wikidata will become more and more useful in all languages we support. One of Wikidata's major goal is supporting smaller Wikipedias. This is one of the most important steps on the way to get us there.
People like Magnus and Denny visualised data that exists in Wikidata, how important do you think visualisation is?


Visualisations are crucial for Wikidata. They are a way for us humans to make sense of the vast amount of data. They allow us to see patterns. They allow us to see where we are missing information. They allow us to see where we have outliers in the data that need closer examination. (Belgium has the information that it shares a border with Australia? Probably not when you look at it on a map...) These things are a lot easier to spot and make sense of when you have a nice visual representation of them. But they also show us how far we have already come and give us a sense of achievement. Look at this gif for example. It shows the progress of adding geocoordinates to Wikidata over the first days this was possible. And last but not less important visualisations are of course beautiful and fun.
What can be done to help people be effective in Wikidata
Make it easy for them to get started and understand the basic concepts quickly. Make it easy for them to find like-minded people for example in the task forces. Keep the number of rules low. Create more tools like Terminator and more Database reports to make it easy to find the areas that need more work.
Do you consider that Wikidata is a project in its own right or is it beholden to the Wikipedias, particularly the biggies?
Wikipedia is definitely the most important use-case for a long time to come. However as we're already seeing now Wikidata's data is of use for many many parties outside Wikimedia as well. This will only increase. It is definitely a project in its own right.
What is your dearest memory of Denny as your predecessor?
I have many dear memories. When we met for the first time a few years ago it was in a small room at our university in Karlsruhe to discuss Semantic MediaWiki and its community and development. It struck me that both Denny and Markus (the two founders of Semantic MediaWiki) just got it. They understood what it means to build a community and develop a project in the open with all its benefits and drawbacks. A very rare trait I can tell you. Since then we've built this amazing project and an incredible community gathered around it. Along the way we've been to Wikimania in Washington, D.C. and Hong Kong and many other events. At each of those events we've met incredible people who are passionate about what we're doing and willing to help. I'll never forget that and I'm looking for more of it to come.

Tuesday, August 27, 2013

The Hammadids of #Algeria

#Wikidata can be #fun. This time it was possible by combining data from several Wikipedias to make a complete list of both the succession of the "sultans" and to complete the genealogy of these people.

Completing such things are not always that straightforward, in this case I found that three rulers were cousins so they had the same grandfather. When one of them is called Nasir ibn Alnas, you can deduce that his father was called Alnas ibn Hammad. As there is no Wikipedia article for several of the Hammadids, I added these missing links in Wikidata.


The Hammadid dynasty occupied their territory and at some stage this territory was absorbed by the Almohad caliphate. Something that does not become clear in the English Wikipedia. The growth and decline of many of these African territories can be nicely seen in this animated map. What would be nice if maps like these are linked for the rulers to Wikidata. It would provide the key to data in many languages.
Thanks,
      GerardM

Friday, August 16, 2013

What to do when #Wikipedia does not provide the information II

King Abd al-Rahman of #Morocco was a nephew of the king that preceded him. His father of mother were probably brothers of king Slimane. As long as I did not know exactly how they are related, the genealogy tool made by Magnus will not show all the rulers of the Alaouite dynasty.

So I did all the usual things to find out:

  • I googled
  • I went to the library
  • I blogged about it
  • I asked on Facebook in a SIG with many people from Morocco
All this did not work.. So I asked a friend at the Tropenmuseum. He asked Mohamed Saadouni who told me that "Moulay Abderrahman is the son of Moulay Hicham, a brother of Moulay Slimane". He even provided me with a reference.



When you are adding statements to Wikidata, it helps when you can can get satisfaction out of the visualisation of the facts. Moulay Hicham exists at this time only in Wikidata, t would be good when be showed as a "red link" as there is no article in any Wikipedia about him. i

When you add data on subjects that have their basis in Africa, you will find that the information in Wikipedia is spotty and that it is very much seen from Western eyes. I am for instance not convinced that Morocco was a sultanate. He is called Moulay Hicham and Wikipedia makes "moulay" equal to "Prince". The current "King" is actually a "Malik".. I do not know enough so I remain puzzled.
Thanks,
      GerardM