Showing posts with label facebook. Show all posts
Showing posts with label facebook. Show all posts

Friday, October 30, 2026

Facebook meddles in science for its own interest

I read an article by Professor Danah Boyd about recently released discovery materials indicating that Meta directly targeted Jonathan Haidt by trying to stir up academics to oppose him. Read the article and honestly Meta deserves all the bad press that it royally deserves.

Professor Boyd was particularly upset for the targeting of Professor Candice L. Odgers so much so that she used "wtaf", an acronym I did not know.

So what to do. Given that Scholia is more or less functional, I did the Wikidata thing; I added a few awards, several recent publications and attributed known publications to the people involved. When you consider the sum of all knowledge, it is what AI systems including the one by Meta use for their training material, it introduces a dilemma. Will it include info in its systems critical of its operations and objectives? If not why trust its systems as a neutral source of intelligence?

Thanks,

       GerardM

Wednesday, July 26, 2017

#Wikidata - in #defence of Erika Herzog

On Facebook, Erika made a few comments that were not well received. A few really positive things did come out as a result but there is a need to defend Erika and her central argument. She asked if there had been a process of consulting the English Wikipedia community because the user interface of Wikidata is so poor. She said:
"... But I am pretty sure a lot of En Wikipedia editors are going to be sort of upset about this shift that requires them to actually edit Wikidata without a form input method (on WikiMarkup). Is there a form input on Visual Editor for this?"
On Facebook she is attacked for all the wrong reasons. A Wikimedia functionary asks: "How is this a Wikidata matter? English Wikipedia is where you want to discuss this." Erika's answer is spot on: "Actually no it's not. I'm tired of this response. It's not helpful or realistic. This is a Wikidata item in terms of buy-in and outreach to incorporate more Wikipedia editors. It's disingenuous to posit otherwise. This needs to be a discussion on both sides, and I think the onus is more on the Wikidata side as the usability and UX is poor at best."

One positive outcome of the Facebook thread is that it is mentioned that there is a method under development to edit Wikidata from Wikipedia templates. However welcome, it is going to introduce its own problems because the primacy of the data remains at Wikidata. The user interface of Wikidata is indeed awful. As one of the more prolific Wikidata editors I only use it for editing. For displaying the data I use Reasonator exclusively. Compare this with this for instance and you will see why.

The reason for this are applicable priorities. The WMF has too many concurrent ambitions for Wikidata and the staff is overextended. When the question is if Wikidata is sufficiently user friendly for an average Wikipedian, the answer is no. At this time Wikidata cannot cope with all the changed committed to it as it is, the wise words of Johan Cruyff apply; every disadvantage has its advantage.
Thanks,
      GerardM

Tuesday, January 07, 2014

#Europeana advertises Thomas Lawrence

On #Facebook Europeana mentions that Thomas Lawrence died on this day in 1830. Europeana brings you a really nice presentation of his work.

Multiple people are known to Wikidata with the name of "Thomas Lawrence", and to know the difference between these men, it helps when there is sufficient information for the process of automated disambiguation.

I added a statement for Mr Lawrence and made him a "painter". At this moment there are 3852 painters known to Wikidata. When a label for painter is added for a language, the disambiguation for all of these people will improve.

Obviously there have been more than 3852 painters. As more painters become known and as more languages have their label for "painter", Wikidata gains value.
Thanks,
    GerardM

Thursday, November 14, 2013

#Facebook knows about #SignWriting


I do not know any Tunisian Sign Language, what I do know is that it is only one of the sign languages that are written in real life in the SignWriting script. Valerie Sutton developed this script. There are many publications that corroborate this. Valerie also developed DanceWriting to document the Danish ballet tradition.

These are two reasons why she should be notable enough for a Wikipedia article in the English language. When you compare this with the many politicians and people playing a sport, it is incredible that they are considered to be notable enough for an article.
Thanks,
      GerardM

Thursday, August 29, 2013

The next billion #Internet users III

At the end of the year the number of Internet users is expected to reach 2,7 billion users. The expectation is that in 2017 there will be 3.7 billion users. This means that in 2017 most people will still not be connected to the Internet.

Recently Mr Zuckerberg of Facebook fame presented Internet.org. It aims to bring the people who are waiting for the "last mile" to be bridged. In an interview in Wired, you can read about the vision behind this project.

The numbers of the Internet Service Providers are from before the announcement of this new project. When people are getting on the Internet even faster, it will certainly change the dynamics of the Internet even more. It is not obvious what data will be most sought after by the people who will be new on the Internet.

With all its encyclopaedic information, Wikipedia seems to be well placed to serve many more people the sum of all knowledge. However, much of that information will not be accessible to the many people because it is not available in a language they know. With Wikidata it will be possible to maintain data and present it in the many languages it supports.

We do want well written articles but presentations of the core data of subjects may fill in the gap.
Thanks,
        GerardM

Thursday, June 07, 2012

Remember #Compuserve ?

Some content can exclusively be found in #Facebook. This makes Facebook a "walled garden". You have to have a Facebook profile or every now and then you find yourself excluded.

For me CompuServe was the original walled garden. It hosted information that I needed for my work. I had to use CompuServe, I had to pay for that privilege and I hated it because it was not that great an experience.

So far, Facebook finances itself by selling stocks and by selling adverts. There is a lot of speculation about future revenue streams following its recent IPO. Premium services that is services you have to pay for are already popping up and really what is more obvious than providing access to restricted content ?

At the time, people were afraid that the CompuServe model would make the Internet less open. Facebook is probably relatively as big as CompuServe was at the time. The best way to deal with walled gardens is to ignore them as much as possible and actively support diversity on the Internet.
Thanks,
     GerardM

Thursday, February 16, 2012

#Facebook, we ARE your partner .. trust us, trust #Wikipedia

#McAfee scans links from Facebook. This would be a good idea when done right. As it is, links to Wikipedia are flagged on Facebook as "potentially unsafe by our trusted partner".

This is rather silly because the Wikimedia Foundation has been a partner of Facebook longer then this new "trusted partner". Facebook, I trust that you can agree that you have got it wrong. It is "wonderful" to have trusted partners who talk on your behalf and get it so magnificently wrong.

As a long time partner we do trust you to do good..
Thanks,
     GerardM

Monday, January 30, 2012

Use #Mail not #Facebook

At the #Wikimedia Foundation we use open standards, free software and for what it is worth we do reach out to people using social media including Facebook. However, if you mean business, you truly want to get me to do something, Facebook does not provide me with the tooling that I need.

When you send me a message, a mail from within Facebook, I have to go into Facebook to read your message and possibly to reply. I do not have that mail in my mail environment. As a consequence I can not readily find it.

Facebook created in its mail a walled garden. I can use Facebook when I want to post some information, an opinion whatever. It is useless to me when people use it to send me mail; I cannot manage the information it contains.
Thanks,
      GerardM

Monday, January 23, 2012

#Facebook or #Google+

My mother decided not to look at her e-mail every day; it prevented her from doing things she likes more; reading a book. With so many options to procrastinate, I do not have too much time for either Facebook or Google+. I do need to follow up on news stories and to do that I use Google reader. I use it for a long time now and it works for me.

Recently the comments I used to add for people who followed me on Reader appear on Google+. This makes both Reader and Google+ more effective for me. People can share my comments and this has resulted in more people following me.

As it is easy and obvious to group people in one or more circles, I can target what to share with whom. It is not that I would not be happy to share this on Facebook, it is just that I do not care for Facebook that much. Personally I feel the same way about it my mother does about e-mail; I have better things to do.
Thanks,
      GerardM

Sunday, October 02, 2011

#Facebook appears to be broken

I have a sweet spot for the #Myanmar #Wikipedia and when I got the message from Zaw Thet Aung that all Wikipedians are taking a long wiki break, I was saddened but not surprised. Saddened because there is such a need for high quality, neutral point of view encyclopaedic information in Myanmar. Not surprised because it is so hard to write articles in the Myanmar language.

What I hope for is for someone to help us with fonts for the WebFonts functionality, combine this with the existing keyboard mappings we support in Narayam and my belief is that the Myanmar community will be enthused when they check this out at translatewiki.net. So much so, that they will enter a bug in bugzilla to enable both extensions asap for all their projects.


When I "View Post on Facebook", the result is underwhelming. It is broken.


It is not that strange that I only now notice Facebook is broken for me. All my posts refer to my blog posts and I have this automated. There is hardly ever a reason for me to Facebook.
Thanks,
       GerardM

Wednesday, August 10, 2011

For the love of #statistics

Planning activities based on statistics is like driving a Formula One car based on what can be seen in the rear mirrors. The problem is that it does not show what is ahead and, it does not show everything what is behind.

The Wikimedia Foundation is increasingly data driven and, consequently it is vital to assess the quality of the data that policies and developments are based on. The data is based on the results of traffic to computers and mobile phones from Wikimedia servers. At the same time the data of Wikipedia, maybe all the Wikipedias, is available to organisations like Facebook. As Wikipedia articles become better available in such a way, it does affect not only the reach of Wikipedia but also the ratio between readers and editors.

Browsers are not the only way to read data from Wikipedia; there are apps for tablets and mobiles that make use of an API to retrieve articles from the WMF servers. These numbers are not included in the statistics either. As apps for tablets and phones are increasingly popular, it is not unlikely that they are yet another factor that confuse a full understanding of the status of the wiki.

When language support is to be provided for all our users, it is important to know to what extend all platforms are used. We know that mobile use is growing rapidly and the numbers of tablets sold is also quite staggering. What should be given priority for support and for language support.. What numbers exist to support whatever choice properly.
Thanks,
       GerardM

Tuesday, July 12, 2011

#Facebook, you are not worth it

People are waiting for an #IPO and you are being hyped as worth more then many industries. Many people are part of your statistics because you are considered must have.

My problem with you; the lack of utility. There is not much in your offerings that makes me actually log in, update my status and do whatever. Oh and yes I connect regularly to Facebook as there are people who want to be my friends. So yes, I am part of your wonderful statistics that show the gullible that the amount considered for you IPO is actually an investment.

The best example of how fickle your position is is best illustrated by the previous king of social networking, MySpace. It was sold for mega dollars to a suspect company and it was sold on for a pittance because it is hard to manage an asset like MySpace and make a profit.


With the advent of Google+ you have another headache. A serious competitor that you cannot buy with the ridiculous amount of cash you may receive from your IPO.  Google+ already has a superior approach compared to yours. It integrates the things I already know, the things that make me productive and it is therefore not the total waste of time you offer.
Thanks,
        GerardM


Friday, April 29, 2011

OMG #Wikipedia is dying

It has been a while but the story of the imminent demise of Wikipedia surfaced again. I always listen with interest to hear what it is this time that will do Wikipedia in. The arguments differ and the time span for the "certain" end is not always the same and if it is not interesting, it is always fun to have a difference of opinions on this subject.

This time there were two reasons why a good thing will come to an end:
  • the parser and the editing interface are crummy
  • there are no new people writing new articles
A relevant point to consider is that Wikipedia for this gentleman is the English language Wikipedia. For me the 270+ other Wikipedias are at least as relevant. Together they grow at double the pace of the English Wikipedia for computers.

The news that Brion is back and will be concentrating on the parser and the editing interface was received as a strong enough promise for an eventual solution. The second point raised more of a discussion; the fact that it is considered the most critical issue facing the Wikimedia Foundation helped. However, then the argument became interesting. These are the things we ended agreeing about
  • Wikipedia became less of a Wiki and more of a Nupedia in its quest for quality
  • a lack of trust and time is why newbies are treated badly
We disagreed about the use of social media. In my view it is best when friends help our newbies find their feet. Real friends are likely to help and, real people are likely to have friends in Wikipedia who are willing to help. Where we disagreed was in how to get such information.

In my view we can ask a newbie if he wants to share his friends on a Hyves or a Facebook. When the newbie does, we are able to find the friends who are Wikimedians. The argument against it is that a Facebook gets information that allows it to build a trust network of Wikipedians. This may have a potential for abuse. What astounded me is that given the choice, it was preferred for Wikipedia to die then to give such a potential to Facebook.

I am glad that I do not have such a grim outlook.
Thanks,
      GerardM

    Thursday, March 31, 2011

    On #Wikipedia we have no friends

    #Facebook is wildly successful because all your "friends" are there. Wikipedia by contrast has a problem growing its community, it is not where you have friends.

    Most of my Facebook friends I know because of a mutual Wikimedia interest. Many of these friends I have met and I would consider helping them when asked. Leigh Thelmadatter came to me for help because I advertised myself as a GLAM ambassador.

    She is preparing a GLAM partnership with a Mexican museum and, I have enjoyed many an interesting conversation with her and was happy to help her with several Tropenmuseum pictures of Mexican objects.

    Conversations among friends are not limited to the business at hand. We talked about education, Mexico, photography, pain in my back ... The photography part provides an other reason how Leigh adds to her Wikimedia relevance; she has uploaded over 5100 pictures taken by her and her husband of the nooks and crannies of Mexico and this makes it an awesome collection.


    As she likes the picture of the San Miguel Concá mission very much and as it clearly demonstrates a different style of church, I nominated it for featured picture.

    I wish that we could all be friends, Wikipedia friends. I wish I could help my friends who come new to Wikipedia. It will help when you can find the friends that are already there. When you make a booboo as a newbie, it is friends who can help you best settling in, who can make you feel welcome.

    Wikipedia is not Facebook, but we can learn from Facebook how to be nice and have friends.
    Thanks,
          GerardM

    Tuesday, January 25, 2011

    I will not be advertising to my "friends" on #Facebook

    At the celebratory #Wikipedia hackathon in Amsterdam we discussed using Facebook for the authenticating of people in a process that was not exclusively Wikimedia. To some this seems like an attractive idea because "everyone" is on Facebook.

    In the past few days, new information became available that makes Facebook increasingly unpalatable.
    • selling private information of the people who use Facebook like addresses to its clients
    • Facebook "currency" to be used for any and all Facebook applications to start with games
    • featuring you in targeted advertisements to your "Facebook friends"

    True to form there has been a backlash against these modifications. It is however a matter of two steps forwards and a step back for now. It will hardly feature on Facebook's radar when I express my contempt on my blog. My hope is that while it may be convenient to use Facebook authentication, the unethical antics of Facebook demonstrate it to be spoiled goods. Something to stay away off.

    In the final analysis Facebook is about making money for its investors. It does it by selling out the people who use Facebook to its customers.
    Thanks,
          GerardM

    Saturday, November 13, 2010

    Facebook FUD

    The latest Facebook FUD is that the mail product that is expected of Facebook will "kill GMAIL and everyone else". In other news it is even said that this new product is tied to an offering by Microsoft.

    Guess what, if there is one thing missing in the social networking world, it is not the offerings by companies like Facebook. Their objective is to profit by selling out the privacy of its customers.

    What is missing is an open source offering that competes with the likes of Facebook. The least it will do is provide an alternative. When such a social networking environment includes the Wikimedia communities, the Wikia communities or short, the Wikimedia movement it will be an environment that is about something.



    Thanks,
          GerardM

    Saturday, October 23, 2010

    Finally some good news about #Facebook

    Facebook is one of those "must have" things at the moment. But from a privacy point of view it is getting from bad to worse. It is good to realise that providing real privacy controls is not in the interest of Facebook. Facebook makes its money by selling you out.

    To make matters worse, there are all these websites that inform Facebook about your actions. This is done by the Facebook connect.

    The good news is that there is an extension for Google Chrome called Facebook disconnect that prevents such data to be send. Currently it is only available for Chrome at the moment, a version for Firefox is expected.
    Thanks,
         GerardM

    Monday, September 06, 2010

    The anti #Wikimania tradition, and other respectable traditions

    It has become a tradition to find fault with the next venue of Wikimania. Too far, politics, gender issues, you name it the arguments you can think off they have been used.

    With the next Wikimania in Haifa, it is again after the next venue has been announced, the contracts have been signed that people find fault. There is a Facebook thingie protesting against it. I guess that the people behind it know that the normal channels have not given them their satisfaction and use Facebook to vent their frustration that they feel they cannot come.

    Apart from dealing with frustration, there is not much to be achieved. There are people who are prevented from coming by their government. The only way to deal with that is by having a future Wikimania in for instance Tehran or Damascus .. I would however prefer Djakarta or Algiers as it is easier on the WMF, it being an USAmerican organisation..

    People who oppose forget how a venue is selected and what Wikimania is about. The candidates select themselves, the volunteers in a country, a chapter spend an inordinate amount of time to get all the details like venue, budget etc right. Another group of volunteers assess the bids by the candidates, they organise public sessions on IRC where the bids are presented and any and all issues are discussed.

    Wikimania is the yearly event where any and all issues can be presented to a worldwide audience. Many people who come are regulars, many people are new and many people are local or near local. For the organising community it is a massive shot in the arm, the benefits to the editors and readers are great.

    Every Wikimania has its special things, every Wikimania has its issues. Wikimania has its traditions, one of them is its troll. We do not need Facebook or other websites for that..
    Thanks,
          GerardM

    Saturday, August 28, 2010

    Sharing pictures

    You go on a holiday, you take a camera and some you upload to #Commons. Well actually, the numbers say you share them on Flickr or Facebook. In a blog Facebook boasts "more than 3 billion photos are being uploaded every month". To appreciate those numbers, Commons has at this moment 7,256,633 freely usable media files or the number of pictures uploaded in its entire existence.


    This is a crop from the only picture of the "la Tomatina" festival in Buñol, Spain. There are not that many pictures of Buñol either .. I am sure that many Wikimedians have been to all kinds of weird and wonderful places, festivals, occasions and went their with their camera. We need them more then Facebook because we actually use them, for instance as illustrations.

    A bee sharing its meal
    The good news is that the Commons usability improvements are something like a month away. This will make it easy to upload. But Facebook is correct when they separate the uploading from the sharing; "5 billion web links, news stories, blog posts, notes, photo albums, etc are shared each week as of earlier this month".

    Geograph picture of the day; Glandford Ford
    We made our GLAM's happy when we shared with them how many of the material they shared with us are used and where. I would be happy to know how many of my Commons contributions are shared and where. I am sure that Geograph would be happy to see the material that we have included in their repository.

    We could even start projecting points on a map for the pictures we have in that location. We could show that we "like" pictures. When we start to celebrate what we have, we have a party and I am sure that many more people will join the fun.
    Thanks,
         GerardM

    Wednesday, July 14, 2010

    The emperor has no clothes


    When I returned from #Wikimania, I received several requests for friendship. Orkut, Facebook, Plaxo .... no requests for friendship from any WMF projects. As social software goes, Facebook is the top dog, the king, the emperor of social media.

    When Wikipedia started, it was truly among the first and the best social software. There was a common goal and, using talk pages, IRC and mailing lists there was a social cohesion that became technically outdated with the advent of social media. Wikimedia is still the top dog, the king, the emperor of open content.

    The problem I have with Facebook is simple; there is no reason to trust it, there is nothing there of interest. The people I befriend are people I know in another setting; the Wiki world. I would love to acknowledge my friendship to them there, improve such a relationship in sharing our interest in projects and having group discussions, announcements.

    I hope that the Wikimedia Foundation will bring such functionality to Wikipedia; it will bring back much of the social cohesion we had in the early days and, it will show that the emperor has no clothes.
    Thanks,
          GerardM