On the day when #Wikipedia is celebrating its 10th birthday with worldwide parties, Anonymous decides to organise a global protest to support WikiLeaks.
To be polite, this is unfortunate. Wikipedia is not related to WikiLeaks and choosing this day is likely to increase the confusion. Several people have found it necessary to stop their work on the Wikimedia projects because of this confusion.
With Anonymous taking the initiative for a day of protest, this confusion is increased. WikiLeaks has no ties with the Wikimedia Foundation and WikiLeaks has no ties with Anonymous. Both the actions of WikiLeaks and Anonymous are considered controversial by some. When the activities of WikiLeaks and Anonymous are considered together, a negative opinion is more easy even obvious. WikiLeaks on its own provides a service that will lead to new thinking on the need for transparency of companies and government.
Given the sad quality of many "news" organisations, WikiLeaks fills in the need that is the consequence of the lack of honesty and the bigotry in the manipulated news they serve.
I will be celebrating 10 years of Wikipedia.
Thanks,
GerardM
Monday, January 10, 2011
Sunday, January 09, 2011
We do not need/want the NPG approach
Our relations with the #GLAM world are friendly and productive. We worked hard to mend fences with the National Portrait Gallery and overcome a sense of weariness particularly in the British museum world.
There was quite some drama when the lawyers of the National Portrait Gallery informed of their intentions to go to court because of material that was craftily copied from its website. Valuable time of lawyers and Wikimedians was spend in order to prevent it from going to court.
This kind of drama is exactly what we do not need. It is therefore disappointing when another website of a museum, this time the Metropolitan Museum of Art can find its high resolution pictures on Commons thanks to a crafty approach to what is available on its website.
It is disappointing because the MET was not even asked if we could have their public domain pictures. It is disappointing because we do not gather the statistics of the MET's traffic with the Baglama tool. It is disappointing because such behaviour does not help us build relations in the GLAM world.
Some people consider that such actions are legal even moral, for me it is short sighted, selfish and stupid.
All this reminded me of the joke of the two bulls on a hill but this other joke is more apt.
GerardM
There was quite some drama when the lawyers of the National Portrait Gallery informed of their intentions to go to court because of material that was craftily copied from its website. Valuable time of lawyers and Wikimedians was spend in order to prevent it from going to court.
This kind of drama is exactly what we do not need. It is therefore disappointing when another website of a museum, this time the Metropolitan Museum of Art can find its high resolution pictures on Commons thanks to a crafty approach to what is available on its website.
It is disappointing because the MET was not even asked if we could have their public domain pictures. It is disappointing because we do not gather the statistics of the MET's traffic with the Baglama tool. It is disappointing because such behaviour does not help us build relations in the GLAM world.
Some people consider that such actions are legal even moral, for me it is short sighted, selfish and stupid.
All this reminded me of the joke of the two bulls on a hill but this other joke is more apt.
A bull called Hannibal eagerly looked at the cows who were put to pasture in a plot next to his. Marshalling all his courage he jumped the fence.
Hello Hannibal mooed one of the cows.. Hello gorgeous. Call me Hanni as my balls are hanging on the barbed wire..Thanks,
GerardM
Use #Wikipedia as a source of reference
The Chronicle Review has a nice article about the paradigm shift that resulted from the growth of Wikipedia as a source of encyclopaedic information. Where you once went to a book store or a library to look up a fact, you now find it on the Internet in your Wikipedia.
There is one more paradigm shift possible, it is when authors on the Internet easily reference to Wikipedia when they refer to a subject that is not universally understood. What is a paradigm shift for instance..
It would be a paradigm shift because Wikipedia would be used as a credible source of Neutral point of View information external to the Wikimedia projects. This has huge benefits all way round;
Organisations like Greenpeace have a rich community of people who know their subjects and as relevant its literatature. This will bolster the quality of the representation of their position in the Wikipedias and questionable sources will become more apparent with increased scrutiny.
Technically the syntax can be something like [[nl:onderwerp ]] or [[ru:предмет]]
Thanks,
GerardM
There is one more paradigm shift possible, it is when authors on the Internet easily reference to Wikipedia when they refer to a subject that is not universally understood. What is a paradigm shift for instance..
It would be a paradigm shift because Wikipedia would be used as a credible source of Neutral point of View information external to the Wikimedia projects. This has huge benefits all way round;
- it provides a shared frame of reference on basic information
- it expands the number of readers of the Wikipedias
- it increases the "google rating" for the webpages that do refer
- the Wikipedias gain a community of people who want to ensure the quality of Wikipedia articles
Organisations like Greenpeace have a rich community of people who know their subjects and as relevant its literatature. This will bolster the quality of the representation of their position in the Wikipedias and questionable sources will become more apparent with increased scrutiny.
Technically the syntax can be something like [[nl:onderwerp ]] or [[ru:предмет]]
Thanks,
GerardM
Friday, January 07, 2011
Bad news from the #Tropenmuseum
Bad news comes soon enough and the news from the Tropenmuseum feels like a harbinger of more bad news to come. The Royal Institute of the Tropics (KIT) will see its subsidy slashed by 4 million Euro. Two million will be the reduction on the budget for the Tropenmuseum.
This is bad news. It is particularly sad when you consider that much of the importance of the Tropenmuseum is in the way it brings other cultures closer to the experience of the people of the Netherlands. As the PVV, a xenophobic party, has a large influence in Dutch politics it feels like a prelude of more things to come.
The Tropenmuseum has proven itself as a friend and its engagement in the Wikimedia world has improved its solid reputation. The Tropenmuseum and KIT are important and its budget cut has made the news. Many other GLAMs will face similar cuts and this will not make the news to this extend.
GLAMs are the repositories of our cultural heritage. As the goal of the Wikimedia movement is to share all knowledge with everyone, they are our natural partners. Less money for museums means less money for digitalisation and outreach. It means that they will be looking for money, for cooperation..
Thanks,
GerardM
This is bad news. It is particularly sad when you consider that much of the importance of the Tropenmuseum is in the way it brings other cultures closer to the experience of the people of the Netherlands. As the PVV, a xenophobic party, has a large influence in Dutch politics it feels like a prelude of more things to come.
The Tropenmuseum has proven itself as a friend and its engagement in the Wikimedia world has improved its solid reputation. The Tropenmuseum and KIT are important and its budget cut has made the news. Many other GLAMs will face similar cuts and this will not make the news to this extend.
GLAMs are the repositories of our cultural heritage. As the goal of the Wikimedia movement is to share all knowledge with everyone, they are our natural partners. Less money for museums means less money for digitalisation and outreach. It means that they will be looking for money, for cooperation..
Thanks,
GerardM
Thursday, January 06, 2011
#translatewiki.net groups the presentation of its #statistics
When a list becomes too big it loses its value. This happened to the language statistics. There are now so many applications and extensions on this list that many of the projects were being drowned out.
With the existing grouping applied to the presentation, it becomes easy to recognise what has been done and what is left to do.
Thanks,
GerardM
![]() |
| Language statistics for Indonesian |
Thanks,
GerardM
Wednesday, January 05, 2011
Disrupting #Wikipedia
With the tenth anniversary of Wikipedia imminent, it is a great moment to consider the value that the Wikimedia movement added by disrupting the status quo.
So there must be clear benefits to disrupt the status quo. The funny thing with disruption is that it implies that business will not be as usual. This means that an able writer who is also an effective misogynist should be banned even though this is not supported by current practices.
Obviously the communities are most valuable but contrary to
what many people say, there is not one community. The readers of the English language Wikipedia are increasingly from non-Anglo-Saxon countries but realising a project of all the towns and villages of India is not yet in the cards.
The Wikimedia Foundation used to concentrate its efforts on the requirements of the "Wikipedia". This made sense given the limited resources that were available. With a budget of more then 10 million dollar this argument lost much of its validity. The WMF strategy made India a target for much of its growth. To realise the potential of India it is important to realise the technical requirements for the Indic languages. This should not lead to the splintering of the technical community as is likely to happen.
When you look at the world from an African perspective, its opportunities are huge.The experience we gained in the Indian subcontinent and Indonesia indicates what can be done if we set our minds to it. There is however not one African perspective in the same way as there is not one African opportunity. When we are willing to realise African opportunities we should look for the best and brightest opportunities and learn what works where.
The biggest disruption, with in my opinion the biggest opportunities, is in creating a chapter for the United States. A chapter organises all the content and community activities in a country, as what is good for the goose is good for then gander there is no real argument to leave the current situation as is. It will leave the Wikimedia Foundation as a global organisation that will fill in the gaps where there is no chapter.
Thanks,
GerardM
- both Wikipedia and Wiktionary are now the most popular projects of its kind
- Commons is an increasingly relevant source of freely licensed media material
- more people have a practical awareness of the value of freely licensed content
- there are many communities who collaborate on freely available and or freely licensed content
So there must be clear benefits to disrupt the status quo. The funny thing with disruption is that it implies that business will not be as usual. This means that an able writer who is also an effective misogynist should be banned even though this is not supported by current practices.Obviously the communities are most valuable but contrary to
what many people say, there is not one community. The readers of the English language Wikipedia are increasingly from non-Anglo-Saxon countries but realising a project of all the towns and villages of India is not yet in the cards.
The Wikimedia Foundation used to concentrate its efforts on the requirements of the "Wikipedia". This made sense given the limited resources that were available. With a budget of more then 10 million dollar this argument lost much of its validity. The WMF strategy made India a target for much of its growth. To realise the potential of India it is important to realise the technical requirements for the Indic languages. This should not lead to the splintering of the technical community as is likely to happen.
When you look at the world from an African perspective, its opportunities are huge.The experience we gained in the Indian subcontinent and Indonesia indicates what can be done if we set our minds to it. There is however not one African perspective in the same way as there is not one African opportunity. When we are willing to realise African opportunities we should look for the best and brightest opportunities and learn what works where.
The biggest disruption, with in my opinion the biggest opportunities, is in creating a chapter for the United States. A chapter organises all the content and community activities in a country, as what is good for the goose is good for then gander there is no real argument to leave the current situation as is. It will leave the Wikimedia Foundation as a global organisation that will fill in the gaps where there is no chapter.
Thanks,
GerardM
Monday, January 03, 2011
Celebrating the next 10 years of #Wikipedia
In January 2001 the first ever Wikipedia article was created. At the time it was nothing special. It was the second attempt to create an encyclopaedia on the Internet. What makes it special is that it succeeded by breaking all the rules in the book and what makes it special is that it has a global appeal.
There is so much to celebrate, 278 Wikipedias represent
277 languages and more languages are waiting in the wings. Commons has 7,980,877 freely available media files. Wiktionaries are playing tag who has the most lemmas.
With so much to be grateful over it is obvious that there is unfulfilled potential. Some of that potential is in growth waiting to happen and some represents things new. With so many languages and supporting chapters, it is great to learn about a first work shop in Sri Lanka, the many celebrations in India, the competitions in Indonesia. As all this potential is realised, the Wikimedia Foundation becomes increasingly global.
My prediction is that this globalisation will affect every project. The neutral point of view will reluctantly become increasingly global and subjects that are still considered exotic will gain the relevance that is now accepted for subjects like Eric Cartman.
Thanks,
GerardM
There is so much to celebrate, 278 Wikipedias represent
277 languages and more languages are waiting in the wings. Commons has 7,980,877 freely available media files. Wiktionaries are playing tag who has the most lemmas.
With so much to be grateful over it is obvious that there is unfulfilled potential. Some of that potential is in growth waiting to happen and some represents things new. With so many languages and supporting chapters, it is great to learn about a first work shop in Sri Lanka, the many celebrations in India, the competitions in Indonesia. As all this potential is realised, the Wikimedia Foundation becomes increasingly global.
My prediction is that this globalisation will affect every project. The neutral point of view will reluctantly become increasingly global and subjects that are still considered exotic will gain the relevance that is now accepted for subjects like Eric Cartman.
Thanks,
GerardM
Women; YES, they can do it
It is #2011. The #Wikipedia mailing lists features two interesting subjects: "how would you disrupt Wikipedia?" and "zero tolerance for misogyny".
The answer to the first question is what the effect can be of the second subject. In our Wikimedia world there are ladies who have proven themselves; they have the star quality being the leading lights in their endeavours.
Given that misogyny is poisoning the well, it is important to realise how many wonderful women we have in our midst despite this and, we should cherish them. As in any volunteer organisation people come and go. I feel the loss of Durova as the loss of a friend. Then again I find it easy to come up with so many names of women who make an impact.
So lets disrupt Wikipedia and give room to all the women who are still on the sidelines and will make a difference.
Thanks,
GerardM
The answer to the first question is what the effect can be of the second subject. In our Wikimedia world there are ladies who have proven themselves; they have the star quality being the leading lights in their endeavours.
Given that misogyny is poisoning the well, it is important to realise how many wonderful women we have in our midst despite this and, we should cherish them. As in any volunteer organisation people come and go. I feel the loss of Durova as the loss of a friend. Then again I find it easy to come up with so many names of women who make an impact.
So lets disrupt Wikipedia and give room to all the women who are still on the sidelines and will make a difference.
Thanks,
GerardM
Tuesday, December 28, 2010
Good news from the #Tropenmuseum
I love good news and particularly good news from friends..
The visitor number for the Tropenmuseum has increased in 2010 by 12% to 197.000. The news about the record number of visitors comes with news of exhibitions in the new year.. one will show contemporary art and the other will show how death has its place in the world.
Thanks,
GerardM
![]() |
| A Tropenmuseum tweet |
Thanks,
GerardM
Sunday, December 26, 2010
#WikiLeaks, naughty or nice
Love them or hate them, WikiLeaks generates strong opinions. This is true in the wide world and it is no different in the Wikipedia world. Recently I blogged about the featured picture candidate of a poster of Julian Assange and it will not feature.
Some of the arguments used not to feature are epic. The prize is for "Julian Assange is from Australia and it should therefore be honour not honor". Apparently there is a difference in Australian and US American honour.
The Signpost has a nice write up with arguments used to argue why leaked documents should or should not be used. What I am missing is perspective; it is not even necessary to quote WikiLeaks as it is renowned publishers like the New York Times who are co-publishers and who put their reputation on the line by publishing this material. When this is not accepted as source material, it becomes even more problematic to accept material from Fox. They are KNOWN to intentionally misrepresent the facts.
Disallowing WikiLeaks material will also damage the basic principle of the neutral point of view. Commons featured picture candidate process again proves to be misnomer; it should be the Commons featured pretty photo candidate process. The quality of the arguments used is the best indicator for its bias.
Thanks,
GerardM
Some of the arguments used not to feature are epic. The prize is for "Julian Assange is from Australia and it should therefore be honour not honor". Apparently there is a difference in Australian and US American honour.
The Signpost has a nice write up with arguments used to argue why leaked documents should or should not be used. What I am missing is perspective; it is not even necessary to quote WikiLeaks as it is renowned publishers like the New York Times who are co-publishers and who put their reputation on the line by publishing this material. When this is not accepted as source material, it becomes even more problematic to accept material from Fox. They are KNOWN to intentionally misrepresent the facts.
Disallowing WikiLeaks material will also damage the basic principle of the neutral point of view. Commons featured picture candidate process again proves to be misnomer; it should be the Commons featured pretty photo candidate process. The quality of the arguments used is the best indicator for its bias.
Thanks,
GerardM
Weihnachten, Christmas 2010
It is becoming a tradition. A #SignWriting card for Christmas.
Looking from the sidelines, it is amazing how SignWriting is slowly but surely gaining acceptance in a world where the written word in the mother tongue is still a novelty. This year has seen many technical innovations that make the goal of a script that has its own Unicode encoding closer.
This year Stephan Woehrmann made two cards that I want to share with you. With many of the structural accomplishments of 2010, I hope that we will see the realisation of at least one Wikipedia in one of the many many sign languages.
That and a merry, merry Christmas and a wonderful new year.
Thanks,
GerardM
Looking from the sidelines, it is amazing how SignWriting is slowly but surely gaining acceptance in a world where the written word in the mother tongue is still a novelty. This year has seen many technical innovations that make the goal of a script that has its own Unicode encoding closer.
This year Stephan Woehrmann made two cards that I want to share with you. With many of the structural accomplishments of 2010, I hope that we will see the realisation of at least one Wikipedia in one of the many many sign languages.
That and a merry, merry Christmas and a wonderful new year.
Thanks,
GerardM
Friday, December 24, 2010
The #Malayalam enigma
Traffic for the Malayalam Wikipedia has gone down dramatically while the number of articles and the number of editors has gone up. WHY??
When you look at the statistics, you will see that traffic halved in a couple of months. So what happened... and as importantly can we do something about it and do we need support to turn this situation around.
The first clue can be found on the main page. It says:
Reading Problems? Click here
There are two scenarios; either you see no text or there are too many spelling errors.
When you look up the word "Karnataka" in English on Google, you get about 10,700,000 results. When you look up the word "കർണ്ണാടക" in Malayalam in Unicode 5.1 you get 2,760 results and when you look up the word "കര്ണ്ണാടക" in Malayalam in Unicode 5.0 you get 117,000 results.
Are you surprised when Wikipedia uses the latest edition of Unicode? Are you surprised when Google makes a difference between two words that are actually the same word written with different characters? The real surprise is that the Malayalam community has found a way to show the same text with fonts in either version of Unicode.
The big fall in traffic is because many people use typing tools that produce Unicode 5.0 to type and search the keywords. Search engines understand them as different. There needs to be canonical equivalence between the old and new Unicode. In the above example, both കര്ണ്ണാടക and കർണ്ണാടക should give the same results.
The question then becomes how do we convince the search giants of this world to include both versions of the written words in their results. The big fall in traffic is due to the conversion of all the Malayalam texts to Unicode 5.1.
The good news is that our Malayalam community is quite happy to help the search engines with conversion software because we want our traffic back.
Thanks,
GerardM
When you look at the statistics, you will see that traffic halved in a couple of months. So what happened... and as importantly can we do something about it and do we need support to turn this situation around.
The first clue can be found on the main page. It says:
There are two scenarios; either you see no text or there are too many spelling errors.
When you look up the word "Karnataka" in English on Google, you get about 10,700,000 results. When you look up the word "കർണ്ണാടക" in Malayalam in Unicode 5.1 you get 2,760 results and when you look up the word "കര്ണ്ണാടക" in Malayalam in Unicode 5.0 you get 117,000 results.
Are you surprised when Wikipedia uses the latest edition of Unicode? Are you surprised when Google makes a difference between two words that are actually the same word written with different characters? The real surprise is that the Malayalam community has found a way to show the same text with fonts in either version of Unicode.
The big fall in traffic is because many people use typing tools that produce Unicode 5.0 to type and search the keywords. Search engines understand them as different. There needs to be canonical equivalence between the old and new Unicode. In the above example, both കര്ണ്ണാടക and കർണ്ണാടക should give the same results.
The question then becomes how do we convince the search giants of this world to include both versions of the written words in their results. The big fall in traffic is due to the conversion of all the Malayalam texts to Unicode 5.1.
The good news is that our Malayalam community is quite happy to help the search engines with conversion software because we want our traffic back.
Thanks,
GerardM
Thursday, December 23, 2010
#IYC2011 - International Year of #Chemistry
As 2011 is the International Year of Chemistry, it can be a stimulus for our Wikipedia communities to share in the fun. On the official website there are many objectives mentioned that make Wikipedia a great platform for many activities.
The stated objectives are very much congruent with Wikimedia goals:
As one of the Public Policy Initiative objectives is to forge collaboration with academia, the IYC2011 makes the worldwide chemistry departments an obvious target for more collaboration.
There are also technical opportunities where MediaWiki and the Wikimedia Foundation can shine. It would be so cool when we finally enable the JMOL functionality in our projects. Another opportunity will present itself when what many call "Wikidata" functionality. There is a plan for a conference on this subject and, there is a wealth of data available for use in our projects.
IYC2011 may make 2011 the year when chemistry gets to the next level of great information in many languages for an important subject.
Thanks,
GerardM
The stated objectives are very much congruent with Wikimedia goals:
- increase appreciation and understanding of chemistry
- increase the interest of young people
- generate enthusiasm for the future of chemistry
- celebrate the role of women and major events in chemistry
As one of the Public Policy Initiative objectives is to forge collaboration with academia, the IYC2011 makes the worldwide chemistry departments an obvious target for more collaboration.
There are also technical opportunities where MediaWiki and the Wikimedia Foundation can shine. It would be so cool when we finally enable the JMOL functionality in our projects. Another opportunity will present itself when what many call "Wikidata" functionality. There is a plan for a conference on this subject and, there is a wealth of data available for use in our projects.
IYC2011 may make 2011 the year when chemistry gets to the next level of great information in many languages for an important subject.
Thanks,
GerardM
About standards
I blogged about collation and standards and, there has been quite some follow up. The most valuable result is an expressed wish to append the CLDR standard with information about Assamese. This is to be tempered with the observation that adding to the CLDR is a painful process. Information new to me is that collation for Indic languages has been added to GNU/C for Tamil and Malayalam and, that an unsuccessful attempt was made to update the CLDR standard.
The sad truth is that it is not always easy to have changes applied to standards. This has benefits and drawbacks. As standards organisations take their time, the result is likely to be of a high quality and it is definitely true that it is easier for known persons and organisations to get results. With a collation order described in a standard, the information necessary to implement collation is available to everyone. It has the added bonus that everyone can be asked to comply with the standard.
The lack of formalised information about a language is the key factor that inhibits a language on the Internet. Asking for the implementation of such rules can only follow.
Thanks,
GerardM
The sad truth is that it is not always easy to have changes applied to standards. This has benefits and drawbacks. As standards organisations take their time, the result is likely to be of a high quality and it is definitely true that it is easier for known persons and organisations to get results. With a collation order described in a standard, the information necessary to implement collation is available to everyone. It has the added bonus that everyone can be asked to comply with the standard.
The lack of formalised information about a language is the key factor that inhibits a language on the Internet. Asking for the implementation of such rules can only follow.
Thanks,
GerardM
Monday, December 20, 2010
Please Danese, help Assamese to get sorted.
On the Assamese #Wikipedia all kinds of things end up in lists. It is because of these lists that things can be found. That is to say, you can find things when the lists are sorted in an intelligible way. The problem for the Assamese is that the collation order we use for their language is "problematic".
The sorting order we use for Assamese is the order in which the characters ended up in Unicode. At translatewiki.net we are asked what can be done to fix this.
What we can do is make sure that the collation order is available in the CLDR. This is where you find the standard collation order for a language. We do make use of the CLDR standard in MediaWiki and this is one of those things where we can make a big difference. We are quite happy to press people to check their sorting order in the CLDR, we are quite happy to have people wait until the standard gets updated. Quite happy because it allows for a solution.
Please Danese, you went to India to learn about what needs doing.. Assamese is also spoken in India...
Thanks,
GerardM
![]() |
| It is not only Assamese tea that needs sorting |
The sorting order we use for Assamese is the order in which the characters ended up in Unicode. At translatewiki.net we are asked what can be done to fix this.
What we can do is make sure that the collation order is available in the CLDR. This is where you find the standard collation order for a language. We do make use of the CLDR standard in MediaWiki and this is one of those things where we can make a big difference. We are quite happy to press people to check their sorting order in the CLDR, we are quite happy to have people wait until the standard gets updated. Quite happy because it allows for a solution.
Please Danese, you went to India to learn about what needs doing.. Assamese is also spoken in India...
Thanks,
GerardM
Sunday, December 19, 2010
A plan for a subsequent photo competition
The Dutch #Wikipedia photo competition Wiki Loves Monuments has been a resounding success and, a text is circulating to do it on an even bigger scale next year. I am happy to use it on my blog as a great example that there are many ways to have photo competitions.
Thanks,
GerardM
Thanks,
GerardM
Summary of this email
Sorry for a long text... We did "Wiki Loves Monuments" in the Netherlands and we would like to do Wiki Loves Monuments again in 2011, but now in Europe. This is possible when many chapters participate. To be clear: this event will only happen on a European level if there is sufficient chapter and community participation to combine efforts. Please feel free to forward this to whomever you find appropriate.
You might have heard before about Wiki Loves Monuments 2010 in the Netherlands. It was a highly successful photo scavenger hunt with 12.500 submissions and over 250 participants. We recently completed a post mortem of this project with a full description and an analysis. There are still many more monuments in the Netherlands which can be photographed and we are considering another run for next year and, we want to give it an European context. Below we will explain how we got where we are, what we have in mind, and what you can become a part of it.
It all started on the Dutch language Wikipedia with the windmill project. One of its main goals was to have an article with an image for every windmill in the Netherlands. Lists were created of windmills per province and statistics were regularly updated to track progress. This approach worked really well and now all the windmills have an article.Volunteers together with the Dutch chapter, managed to get a dataset of all 60.000 "Rijksmonumenten" ie buildings/objects with some historical or cultural relevance from the "Rijksdienst voor het Cultureel Erfgoed". This marked the birth of the "Rijksmonumenten" project. The project uses the lessons learned in the windmill project. The data from the RCE was converted into lists by location and put on the Dutch Wikipedia. The community started improving the lists by adding missing information and by adding photo's.
In June 2009 Wikimedia Nederland ran Wiki Loves Art /NL This was a photo scavenger hunt in more than 40 museums. It was quite successful, 5.400 photos, but it was much more laborious because we needed to keep contacts with all the participating museums and the nearest museum was usually further away from people's homes than the nearest monument.
For 2010 we were looking for a nice topic for a photo competition. The "Rijksmonumenten" project was running very well so we decided to organize Wiki Loves Monuments to give this project a boost.So, what could a European WLM look like? Obviously it is very much open for debate but we are trying to incorporate the lessons learned in the Netherlands into a European model. We think it will work best with national Wiki Loves Monuments projects and international cooperation, shared resources and international prizes. The national contests do not have to be identical, but similarity will prove to be practical. We are not sure yet what countries would be most successful, but initially we are considering the EU chapter countries and Switzerland ...
Wiki Loves Monuments would run in the month of September 2011, and participants will submit photos of monuments which are part of a list of monuments. This list includes the addresses and maybe the geo-coordinates of all the identified monuments. In each participating country there will be some prizes available, to be awarded by a jury for that country and the best will be competing for prizes in an European final.Most of the local work will be to get a database with the objects and create object lists from that. Dutch volunteers can support you as they have the experience. You will need to communicate to get the community and the public informed. You will need to find a jury and prizes for them to award. We can help with example press releases, best practices, templates and list examples and community motivation.
So, what to do when you like the idea? First of all check with your collegues (at the board, other members, community) what they think of it. You will need several people to run such a project. The next step is to analyse your local situation: who would be good partners (who keeps the lists of monuments?) for you, how many monuments are there in your country, are they well spread? Roughly how much information/photos is already available and are there community members already active in this field?We already registered www.wikilovesmonuments.eu and are in touch with CARARE and Europeana who may help us by laying contacts with European Union cultural heritage organizations. This will stress the European context and the impact this may have. The most important partner in each country will be the one that maintains a database with bational monuments, and may release this to you. Such a database/list is crucial for the success of such an event.
Please inform us when you are interested in joining in such European event. When there is enough enthusiasm, we will create a special (easy to join) mailing list to coordinate efforts and to allow the volunteers to join in the discussions. We took the liberty of discussing this with some chapters, and are hopeful that it will actually become the first grand chapter cooperation program. You can already join #wikilovesmonuments on freenode irc when you are interested.
With kind regards,
Maarten Dammers
Lodewijk Gelauf
A photo competition with a twist
We need illustrations for our #Wikipedia articles and it is tough to find high quality pictures of those parts of the world where Wikipedians are rare. Both Albania and Kosovo are not well covered with Wikipedians, our Wikipedias do not cover these areas particularly well either and there is a lack of high quality pictures to illustrate such articles.
Organising a photo competition makes sense but a standard competition has a few drawbacks:
Organising a photo competition makes sense but a standard competition has a few drawbacks:
- it is time limited
- it does not necessarily build skills
- judging photos is a serious pain in the posterior
Nominating a picture is easy but qualifying is hard. Technical requirements for digital photos are high and jealously enforced. This removes the need for the organisers to judge the pictures themselves. This competition has already generated quite a lot of pictures by several photographers and the quality is improving.
This competition has it all;
- we gain many new pictures about an area we know little about
- the competitors gain valuable skills
- Commons and Wikipedia become better known in Kosovo and Albania
It will be interesting to learn when the competition has ended.
Thanks,
GerardM
Saturday, December 18, 2010
OMG who killed #Flickr
The story of the demise Flickr has been overly exaggerated. Unlike delicous, it is only rumour mongering as far as I can see. With Yahoo obviously in trouble, it is a good moment to reflect on the relevance of Flickr for GLAMs anyway.
Remember all the conferences where Flickr was praised as a platform to bring museum and archive collections to the people? Well, for quite some time now they do not provide support for new GLAMs to join the program.
I am sure that like Kenny, there will be a next chapter in the evolving drama. Unlike Flickr Wikimedia Commons is very much still in business to welcome new cooperation with GLAMs that will bring its cultural heritage to a global audience. The number of conferences where you may have heard about the possibilities are rising and there are plenty of people, myself included, who will be happy to help you in the direction of Commons.
Thanks,
GerardM
Remember all the conferences where Flickr was praised as a platform to bring museum and archive collections to the people? Well, for quite some time now they do not provide support for new GLAMs to join the program.
I am sure that like Kenny, there will be a next chapter in the evolving drama. Unlike Flickr Wikimedia Commons is very much still in business to welcome new cooperation with GLAMs that will bring its cultural heritage to a global audience. The number of conferences where you may have heard about the possibilities are rising and there are plenty of people, myself included, who will be happy to help you in the direction of Commons.
Thanks,
GerardM
Friday, December 17, 2010
Making Dutch orphan works available to the public
The Dutch National Archive and Pictoright, a branch organisations for copyright holders of graphic and illustrative material have come to an agreement to make digitised material that is without a known rights holder.
As part of the "images for the future" digitisation project there is so much material without known rights holders that it is impossible to research them all. The agreement makes it possible for the Nationaal Archief to make all the digitised pictures available on its website.
This is good. This is important. However... when the images are to be made available elsewhere on the Internet, payments are still required and it will be Pictoright that will do the research into the rights holders. Maximising the money generated will allow Pictoright to do the best it can.
The experience with the Bundesarchiv proved that making images restricted in size to Commons made a huge difference to the sale of high resolution images. It would be wonderful if we can persuade the parties involved to share with us this treasure trove so that we can better illustrate our projects and they will make more money.
Thanks,
GerardM
As part of the "images for the future" digitisation project there is so much material without known rights holders that it is impossible to research them all. The agreement makes it possible for the Nationaal Archief to make all the digitised pictures available on its website.
| Women protesting the 1980 abortion law |
This is good. This is important. However... when the images are to be made available elsewhere on the Internet, payments are still required and it will be Pictoright that will do the research into the rights holders. Maximising the money generated will allow Pictoright to do the best it can.
The experience with the Bundesarchiv proved that making images restricted in size to Commons made a huge difference to the sale of high resolution images. It would be wonderful if we can persuade the parties involved to share with us this treasure trove so that we can better illustrate our projects and they will make more money.
Thanks,
GerardM
Labels:
Commons,
copyright,
GLAM,
Netherlands,
orphan works
#Wikileaks and #Wikimedia #Commons
This picture of Julian Assange is a featured picture candidate. The arguments used against the featuring of this picture are in my opinion pathetic.
Commons is a repository of media files. These are primarily used to illustrate Wikimedia projects. Wikipedia articles are to provide a neutral point of view and consequently there is a need for illustrations for any point of view. Given that Wikinews is one of our projects, this is an appropriate time to support illustrations like this. It is not a digital photo and consequently the size of the file is irrelevant. The notion that works like this have to be in the svg format is as bizarre as the notion that the picture itself has to be notable.
Thanks,
GerardM
Commons is a repository of media files. These are primarily used to illustrate Wikimedia projects. Wikipedia articles are to provide a neutral point of view and consequently there is a need for illustrations for any point of view. Given that Wikinews is one of our projects, this is an appropriate time to support illustrations like this. It is not a digital photo and consequently the size of the file is irrelevant. The notion that works like this have to be in the svg format is as bizarre as the notion that the picture itself has to be notable.
Thanks,
GerardM
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


























