Monday, March 03, 2014
#Wikidata - #bots help place objects on the #map
The Sanandaj airport "is in the administrative-territorial entity" of the "Howmeh Rural District". Information like this is harvested by a bot from a template in Wikipedia. It checks that the lowest level of such an entity is registered. When for instance a "province" is registered in stead of the "county", the province will be replaced. In this way we make good use of the available information and the information provided gains in relevance.
For some countries it is the first time this functionality runs. It will make an impact on Nepal and Iran for instance. On other countries it will be at least a second run. The USA for instance will see changes to many if not all counties, townships and cities.
When the complete administrative or territorial structure for a country is available, the Reasonator will bring the best out of the available information. This will show even more clearly when categories and lists include the statements that run the relevant queries. The result can be compared with the content of the lists and categories. This makes for a tool that helps people complete the information provided in their Wikipedia.
Thanks,
GerardM
#Wikidata - a village in #Iran
Both the Persian language Wikipedia and the English language Wikipedia have articles on villages, cities, qanaats, rivers and cultural heritage sites in Iran. The first goal Wikidata addressed is connecting the articles on the same topic. The village of Shurabeh-ye Sofla Do is a village in Iran. It is not connected to one of the many unconnected items that are villages in Iran but written in Persian.
When the villages and associated information are properly annotated with statements, it becomes easier to recognise that what the en.wp offers and what the fa.wp offers is the same. As it is, it is just obvious that there is a need for people who care about subjects like the villages, municipalities, counties and districts in practically every country.
My impression is that with the move of the interlanguage links or interwiki links to Wikidata, many people who were involved in creating such links have moved to something new to do. The need for their bots was no longer there.
Obviously an impression is just that. It takes research to learn if an observation truly reflects what is happening.
Thanks,
GerardM
Sunday, March 02, 2014
#Wikidata - missing interwiki links
In the last few months many items were added to Wikidata for #Wikipedia articles that did not have any known interwiki links. They were added wholesale or they were added one at a time. One at a time to include a missing relative or to add the missing village in a district or ...
When they are added, there is no attention for possible interwiki links. Where to start? There are 280+ candidates where there could be an article.
In the Wikimedia Research Newsletter of Februari 2014, it is suggested that "transitivity is a moot point". This is wrong for two reasons: only two languages are considered and Wikidata does not change the mechanics in such a study. The second reason is that while Wikidata has a sizeable amount of contributors, it is not obvious at all what people are working on or that things changed that much from before the introduction of inter language links in Wikidata.
I like this research and as far as I am concerned there may well be 165,000 missing links for the combination English and Portuguese. There are plenty items that have missing article links and, there are plenty items in Wikidata that should be merged.
I cannot wait for research that takes Wikidata seriously and does not start from false assumptions.
Thanks,
GerardM
When they are added, there is no attention for possible interwiki links. Where to start? There are 280+ candidates where there could be an article.
In the Wikimedia Research Newsletter of Februari 2014, it is suggested that "transitivity is a moot point". This is wrong for two reasons: only two languages are considered and Wikidata does not change the mechanics in such a study. The second reason is that while Wikidata has a sizeable amount of contributors, it is not obvious at all what people are working on or that things changed that much from before the introduction of inter language links in Wikidata.
I like this research and as far as I am concerned there may well be 165,000 missing links for the combination English and Portuguese. There are plenty items that have missing article links and, there are plenty items in Wikidata that should be merged.
I cannot wait for research that takes Wikidata seriously and does not start from false assumptions.
Thanks,
GerardM
Friday, February 28, 2014
#Wikidata - Maurice Rose, a highly decorated US major general
Mr Rosen was the highest ranking US officer during the second world war who was of Jewish decent. As you can see, he was well educated, highly decorated and as he fought in both world wars, he had plenty of combat experience. He died in combat and was buried on the American war cemetery in Maargraten.
This blog post serves two purposes; I wanted some personal balance following a recent blog post. I also wanted to show how diverse the Jewish experience has been during the second world war. This is the third post at that.
Thanks,
GerardM
Magnus on #Wikidata in #Cambridge - part II
You probably could not make it to Magnus's presentation about Wikidata. That is the sad news. The good news is that the slides of his talk are available for all of us to see.
The presentation is well structured, it explains clearly what Wikidata is about and the tools ecosystem gets its attention. When you present, you have to fit the information in the allotted time frame; it follows that there is more to show, more to explain. Much of this can be found by reading Magnus's blog. In addition to this there is always this blog. As always, questions remarks suggestions are very welcome.
Thanks,
GerardM
#Wikidata - Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross
On my random journey through Wikidata, I came across Wilhelm Cirener. All that was known about him was that he died in 1941. The only article about him was in Portuguese. I had a look and found that he was awarded the Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross.
There is a category with 1101 entries. It was easy enough to make all items both "human" and recipients of this military award. It also shows that there are people working on completing articles for all recipients of the Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross.
When I blogged about Kalonymus Kalman Shapira, I was able to identify only 586 people who died in the holocaust. I hope there are people working on expanding their number in both Wikipedia and Wikidata.
Diversity is very much about balance. With so many Nazis considered to be notable and so few victims represented the balance is wrong.
Thanks,
GerardM
There is a category with 1101 entries. It was easy enough to make all items both "human" and recipients of this military award. It also shows that there are people working on completing articles for all recipients of the Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross.
When I blogged about Kalonymus Kalman Shapira, I was able to identify only 586 people who died in the holocaust. I hope there are people working on expanding their number in both Wikipedia and Wikidata.
Diversity is very much about balance. With so many Nazis considered to be notable and so few victims represented the balance is wrong.
Thanks,
GerardM
Thursday, February 27, 2014
#Wikidata - Marga Minco, a Dutch author and journalist
The "bitter herb" is a book by Mrs Minco that many Dutch people read when they were in high school. It is short and written in an easy way. The obvious question you had to be prepared for was: "please explain the title".
Mrs Minco is Jewish and during the German occupation, she saved her life by going into hiding. After the war she wrote a large number of books and only two are known at this time to Wikidata. She married, had a child became a widow.
Mrs Minco proved to be a great example to explain both about Wikidata and Reasonator. I spoke with someone from India and he got the basic information about Mrs Minco. He understood that when labels for the basic properties and qualifiers are entered, much of the information would be understandable in Gujarati, Tamil, Sindhi or Nepali.
Even better, the same basic information helps annotate Gujarati, Tamil, Sindhi or Nepali authors as well. At this stage a lot of work goes into a more complete annotation. Several of the awards were not known to Wikidata. Her husband and child needed work even though they both have Wikipedia articles. What is not clear how you indicate that someone went into hiding. As it has been quite traumatic, it is important enough to include it when you annotate the life of an author.
Thanks,
GerardM
Mrs Minco is Jewish and during the German occupation, she saved her life by going into hiding. After the war she wrote a large number of books and only two are known at this time to Wikidata. She married, had a child became a widow.
Mrs Minco proved to be a great example to explain both about Wikidata and Reasonator. I spoke with someone from India and he got the basic information about Mrs Minco. He understood that when labels for the basic properties and qualifiers are entered, much of the information would be understandable in Gujarati, Tamil, Sindhi or Nepali.
Even better, the same basic information helps annotate Gujarati, Tamil, Sindhi or Nepali authors as well. At this stage a lot of work goes into a more complete annotation. Several of the awards were not known to Wikidata. Her husband and child needed work even though they both have Wikipedia articles. What is not clear how you indicate that someone went into hiding. As it has been quite traumatic, it is important enough to include it when you annotate the life of an author.
Thanks,
GerardM
#Wikipedia in #Persian can find any subject
When you expand your horizon, there is more to be found. As you can see in the screenshot, when you search for Jan Wolkers, an award winning Dutch author, you will actually find something. As you may know, Wikidata has information in any language. By adding the Wikidata Search functionality to the Wikipedia extended search, more information will be brought to you.
Statistics prove that people are finding these results. It does provide results that are part of the "long tail" but these numbers add up. It is how we "share in the sum of all knowledge that is available to us".
Thanks,
GerardM
#Wikidata - the #US secretary of #education
In Wikidata, we care about the items that have a relevance. It is why we care about the "United States Secretary of Education". Reasonator shows the incumbent Mr Duncan, the seal of the office, the topic's main category and in related media, pictures of the predecessors of Mr Duncan.
When you analyse the Wikipedia articles that are linked to this item, you will find that some of them are lists. A growing consensus in Wikidata has it that in order for them to be connected to the singular subject, we just have to ignore the fact that a Wikipedia calls it a list.
One consequence is that the label used for the language(s) involved will have to be singular as well. The one issue that may prove problematic is when there are Wikipedias that have both an article about the singular subject and an article that lists them all. This is however not really a Wikidata problem.
Thanks,
GerardM
Wednesday, February 26, 2014
#Wikidata - #soccer players from #Brazil
Soccer is probably the most popular game in the world. Many of the best players are from Brazil. The English Wikipedia has a category for them and it includes 4907 pages. Of these pages, 4718 have a Wikidata item.
At the start there were some 527 Brazilian soccer players known to Wikidata. Using this category all the items were made a "human" a "Brazilian" and a "football player". The result is that Wikidata now knows about 4727 "Brazilian soccer players".
Obviously, when the missing items are added, there will be a few hundred more people known to be Brazilian soccer players. When the same process is executed on the category for Brazilian soccer players even more people are likely to be known as such.
Obviously this same process could be done for soccer players from Britain, Russian, the Netherlands, France, Cameroon...
There is enough left to do so join in the fun.
Thanks,
GerardM
At the start there were some 527 Brazilian soccer players known to Wikidata. Using this category all the items were made a "human" a "Brazilian" and a "football player". The result is that Wikidata now knows about 4727 "Brazilian soccer players".
Obviously, when the missing items are added, there will be a few hundred more people known to be Brazilian soccer players. When the same process is executed on the category for Brazilian soccer players even more people are likely to be known as such.
Obviously this same process could be done for soccer players from Britain, Russian, the Netherlands, France, Cameroon...
There is enough left to do so join in the fun.
Thanks,
GerardM
Tuesday, February 25, 2014
#Reasonator - eye candy
There is no particular reason why I show Mr Trent to good effect. It is just that Reasonator makes him look good.
Thanks,
Gerard
Thanks,
Gerard
#Wikidata - bots at work
When you roam through Wikidata using the Reasonator, you will find a lot of qanats. They are water works of a different kinds and they are equally important. These water works prevent starvation.
For many of them there are articles in the Wikipedia in Persian and, the only thing known was that they were qanats. I asked a friend and he told me that it was known in what "administrative-territorial entity" they are. As you can see in the screen print, that one is in the Kahak District of Iran.
The only problem was, Reasonator did not show it. Adding the fact that the Kahak District is part of Qom County proved enough to show 221 items, all qanats. My friend will add the other (missing) counties to districts. It will not only enrich the information about qanats but as relevantly also about Iran itself.
What I would like to see is to have all the villages, cities and what not be as well covered for Iran as it is for China. China has at this moment the best coverage of its administrative system.
Thanks,
GerardM
#Wikidata - it is not #execution; it is a matter of #semantics
Kalonymus Kalman Shapira was a Polish rabbi who died in the Trawniki concentration camp. At the end of the war, the Nazis decided to execute all the remaining prisoners of the concentration camps in operation in operation "Harvest Festival". Mr Shapira was shot.
The manner of death is an execution. However, I can not make myself add this as a statement of fact for Mr Shapira. The reason for this is that execution is considered a synonym of "capital punishment". Capital punishment has as its narrative: "legal process whereby a person is put to death by the state as a punishment for a crime". The Neurenberg trials have concluded that what happened may have been expedient but it was absolutely not legal.
The number of notable people who died in a Nazi concentration camp seems to be low. Only 586 people among many false positives.
Thanks,
GerardM
The manner of death is an execution. However, I can not make myself add this as a statement of fact for Mr Shapira. The reason for this is that execution is considered a synonym of "capital punishment". Capital punishment has as its narrative: "legal process whereby a person is put to death by the state as a punishment for a crime". The Neurenberg trials have concluded that what happened may have been expedient but it was absolutely not legal.
The number of notable people who died in a Nazi concentration camp seems to be low. Only 586 people among many false positives.
Thanks,
GerardM
Monday, February 24, 2014
Magnus on #Wikidata in #Cambridge
When you happen to be in the neighbourhood of Cambridge on 27 February 2014, you have the option to attend a lecture where Dr Magnus Manske will give a presentation on Wikidata. According to the information, you may "learn more about all its functionality, how it works, and how it will change the future!”.
For the rest of us, we have experienced how Wikidata has developed and how Reasonator makes information out of Wikidata's data. There is a lot to all the tools that Magnus developed, tools like WDQ, AutoList WD-FIST.
Being a fly on the wall in the Plant Sciences Lecture Theatre, Downing Site is an ambition. However, I will happily report about the developments of both Wikidata and the tools that Magnus is famous for.
Thanks,
GerardM
For the rest of us, we have experienced how Wikidata has developed and how Reasonator makes information out of Wikidata's data. There is a lot to all the tools that Magnus developed, tools like WDQ, AutoList WD-FIST.
Being a fly on the wall in the Plant Sciences Lecture Theatre, Downing Site is an ambition. However, I will happily report about the developments of both Wikidata and the tools that Magnus is famous for.
Thanks,
GerardM
Sunday, February 23, 2014
#Wikipedia categories are #lists and an #ontology in a way.
When you look at Wikipedia categories, they refer to articles that fit certain criteria. What you may also find other more specialised categories and "meta articles".
Take for instance the category "Painters by Nationality". You will expect that all articles about people; they are "human" and they are all painters. The category "Indian painters" includes painters who have the Indian nationality. It has a subcategory "Indian woman painters" they have the female gender.
When people want to know their names in Hindi, Gujarati or Telugu, they can find them and even add the missing ones.
By implication, suggestions for Wikidata statements can be made when articles are added to categories. They are what defines the "list" in Wikidata. Suggestions can be ignored but the consequence is that Wikidata will not know them as belonging in that category.
Suggesting what categories articles belong to is much harder. However, when an article on the same subject exists in another language, categories that are shared between the languages are obvious targets.
All this hinges on a shared understanding of what categories are.
Thanks,
GerardM
Take for instance the category "Painters by Nationality". You will expect that all articles about people; they are "human" and they are all painters. The category "Indian painters" includes painters who have the Indian nationality. It has a subcategory "Indian woman painters" they have the female gender.
When people want to know their names in Hindi, Gujarati or Telugu, they can find them and even add the missing ones.
By implication, suggestions for Wikidata statements can be made when articles are added to categories. They are what defines the "list" in Wikidata. Suggestions can be ignored but the consequence is that Wikidata will not know them as belonging in that category.
Suggesting what categories articles belong to is much harder. However, when an article on the same subject exists in another language, categories that are shared between the languages are obvious targets.
All this hinges on a shared understanding of what categories are.
Thanks,
GerardM
Saturday, February 22, 2014
#Wikidata project - Actors from #India
#Wikidata becomes useful when there are many items that are connected. Lists and categories connect items because they imply that statements on all items are shared.
Lists and categories can be defined with properties that can be used to run a query. Important is that the inverse is true as well. A Wikipedia list or category implies that particular statements are true for the items that exist on a list or in a category.
A category like "Actors in Hindi cinema" indicates:
Lists and categories can be defined with properties that can be used to run a query. Important is that the inverse is true as well. A Wikipedia list or category implies that particular statements are true for the items that exist on a list or in a category.
A category like "Actors in Hindi cinema" indicates:
- "instance of" "human"
- "profession" "actor / actress"
- "language" "Hindi"
It does not imply that these actors have the "nationality" of "India". This is implied by the category "Indian film actors".
Thanks to WDQ, it is possible to know which actors who play in Hindi movies do not have the Indian nationality. This query makes it possible for people who care about Bollywood to consider the nationality of the 224 actors who fit this query.
This describes actionable information of a project. Your project can be done in the same way. You add data using AutoList or WD-Fist and Reasonator will display the information in an attractive way. These are tools that provide you grip on your projects. Wikidata provides you with information that may exist in any or none of the Wikipedias.
Thanks,
GerardM
Labels:
Best practices,
FIST,
India,
projects,
Reasonator,
WDQ,
Wikidata
Friday, February 21, 2014
#Reasonator does lists
What is the point of defining in #Wikidata the "is a list of" property when it does not provide a benefit. So far there was no point. With the latest functionality of the Reasonator, it shows what the list contains based on the definition.
Obviously that is not what the different Wikipedias may have in mind. Typically a list contains of existing articles and the odd red-link. Querying Wikidata will provide you with all items that conform to set criteria... all of them. It is the perfect list when all the items that should be on the list conform.
Obviously, many lists are incomplete because many items have not been populated with statements that make them show up. In the example, the English category "List of Indian film directors" is a great place to start adding the statements "instance of" "human", "occupation" "film director" and "country of citizenship" "India". This is what you can do using the AutoList. It results in what you can see above.
To make the result look pretty, there is FIST, this tool allows you to use the same category to add images that are available on Commons and are used in an image in a single click.
When you are really into a specific subject, these are great tools that help you set up basic information. Friends who know different languages can help open up the information in their language.
When there is no information about specific subjects, Wikidata is your best bet to make it widely available and, Reasonator is what makes it look good.
Thanks,
GerardM
Labels:
AutoList,
Best practices,
FIST,
India,
Reasonator,
Wikidata
Thursday, February 20, 2014
United we stand strong, divided we still are
This is a #map of Elburg, a municipality in the Netherlands. It shows its monuments and when available it will show a picture for them thanks to Wiki loves Monuments. There is a pop up for every individual monument and it shows a wealth of information.
According to the Wikipedia article, there are 293 monuments in Elburg alone. The information is rich; it includes descriptions, geo-locations, external sources and a link to Google Maps. This is a great choice because it allows you to see all the monuments while virtually travelling through this small town.
When this information becomes available in Wikidata, it becomes possible to find translations for many of the data items in use. The monuments in the Elburg can be found with a query like this one. The existing list article can be defined like this. For all the 293 items a new Wikidata has to be created and populated with the existing data.
This blog post indicates that it can be done. The problem is that it requires a retooling of Wikimedia loves Monuments. To the people who worked so hard to build the existing tooling the message is: it is the work you did that makes it possible to have quick results in Wikidata in the first place.
Thanks,
GerardM
#Wikidata - a picture paints a thousand words
One of the features of the #Reasonator is that it will indicate when pictures are available in #Wikipedia articles. It takes several steps to add a picture and, many pictures have been added in this way.
With the latest iteration of FIST, the Free Image Search Tool, Magnus has revamped an existing tool and gave it a new lease of life as a tool for Wikidata. While you are involved in a certain theme like "Nobel laureates in Economics" or "Authors of India" it is really powerful when all the items use one of the images used in a Wikipedia.
As a tool for Wikidata FIST is still raw around its edges, it may time out its session for instance. However, it is such a nice tool; it deserves to be used.
Thanks,
GerardM
With the latest iteration of FIST, the Free Image Search Tool, Magnus has revamped an existing tool and gave it a new lease of life as a tool for Wikidata. While you are involved in a certain theme like "Nobel laureates in Economics" or "Authors of India" it is really powerful when all the items use one of the images used in a Wikipedia.
As a tool for Wikidata FIST is still raw around its edges, it may time out its session for instance. However, it is such a nice tool; it deserves to be used.
Thanks,
GerardM
#Wikidata - about an #organisation
Organisations like the #Wikimedia Foundation, are governed by people. The composition of the people with power or influence changes over the years and, while some organisations are identifiably managed by one person, typically there are structures in place like a "board of trustees" or a "board of directors" or whatever they are called.
To understand the notability of people, it is often important to know of what boards they are a member of. This defines their influence and, for the WMF the people who decide(d) on the issues of the WMF are in its board of trustees.
Once all these people were included in Wikidata, when all the start dates and end dates were included, the "related media" of the Reasonator produced a nice composition of all of them. The time line proved interesting as well. Phoebe is included twice; there was one year when she was no board member. This also shows when you click on the "show items" for the 24 items of "member of".
The information of the Wikimedia Foundation itself is interesting as well. It does show a logo (thank you Magnus) but it does not show many other things for instance its managing director. Particularly for people, their notability is often defined by the influence they wield. This influence is defined in the many relations people have. It is quite similar to politicians. For them we are quite comfortable including the offices they have held.
Thanks,
GerardM
To understand the notability of people, it is often important to know of what boards they are a member of. This defines their influence and, for the WMF the people who decide(d) on the issues of the WMF are in its board of trustees.
Once all these people were included in Wikidata, when all the start dates and end dates were included, the "related media" of the Reasonator produced a nice composition of all of them. The time line proved interesting as well. Phoebe is included twice; there was one year when she was no board member. This also shows when you click on the "show items" for the 24 items of "member of".
The information of the Wikimedia Foundation itself is interesting as well. It does show a logo (thank you Magnus) but it does not show many other things for instance its managing director. Particularly for people, their notability is often defined by the influence they wield. This influence is defined in the many relations people have. It is quite similar to politicians. For them we are quite comfortable including the offices they have held.
Thanks,
GerardM
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

.jpg)





