Monday, December 02, 2013
#Wikidata #serendipity - Valerie Aurora
In a demonstration, searching for a "Valerie" I just picked one. It was Valerie Aurora and as I met her in Berlin, it was nice to add some extra additional information. Above is her "Reasonator" page shown in Russian. As you can see, her father has a label in Russian and the labels for "computer scientist" and "activist" need to be added.
What would be useful is for the Reasonator functionality itself to be internationalised and localised.
Thanks,
GerardM
Sunday, December 01, 2013
#Wikidata - date of #death; Paul Walker
Mr Walker who happens to be an actor died in a car crash. Wikidata is an appropriate place to record the passing away of notable people.
So far when I read that someone died, I added the date of his demise. He or she then appeared on a query of recent deaths. Now I increasingly find that people are there ahead of me.
The result of this query is really encouraging; increasingly there are people not known to the English Wikipedia and some are not even known in the English language.
Currently 322 people are known to Wikidata to have died since October 1 and 208 died in the month of October. While there is no official query functionality yet, this existing labs functionality is really powerful. The results often prove to be motivating particularly when they show Wikidata progress.
Thanks,
GerardM
So far when I read that someone died, I added the date of his demise. He or she then appeared on a query of recent deaths. Now I increasingly find that people are there ahead of me.
The result of this query is really encouraging; increasingly there are people not known to the English Wikipedia and some are not even known in the English language.
Currently 322 people are known to Wikidata to have died since October 1 and 208 died in the month of October. While there is no official query functionality yet, this existing labs functionality is really powerful. The results often prove to be motivating particularly when they show Wikidata progress.
Thanks,
GerardM
Friday, November 29, 2013
Isabella Karle - A notable scientist
A nice article about Mrs Karle indicated that while her husband was awarded the Nobel prize, and he felt that she should have been in on that same prize, she was awarded more prizes than he did.
This controversy is in itself not that interesting. More relevant is what Wikidata has to say about her. It turned out that many of the awards she received were missing and, that is easily enough rectified. What you learn in the process is how to indicate an "honorary degree". That Gregori Aminov does have his Wikidata item and that the full name of the "Bower award" is the "Bower Award and Prize for Achievement in Science"..
One award she received that still needs to be added is the "Women in Science and Engineering’s Lifetime Achievement Award". Multiple sources indicate that Mrs Karle received this award but there is no Wikipedia article about this prize and, the sources do not indicate who awarded this prize. Google does not really help either.
Diversity is and particularly women in science are considered to be important. Making sure that the information about notable women in science is of the highest quality is one way to celebrate their accomplishments. It would be really good if someone is able to add the lady scientists who received this lifetime achievement award.
Thanks,
GerardM
This controversy is in itself not that interesting. More relevant is what Wikidata has to say about her. It turned out that many of the awards she received were missing and, that is easily enough rectified. What you learn in the process is how to indicate an "honorary degree". That Gregori Aminov does have his Wikidata item and that the full name of the "Bower award" is the "Bower Award and Prize for Achievement in Science"..
One award she received that still needs to be added is the "Women in Science and Engineering’s Lifetime Achievement Award". Multiple sources indicate that Mrs Karle received this award but there is no Wikipedia article about this prize and, the sources do not indicate who awarded this prize. Google does not really help either.
Diversity is and particularly women in science are considered to be important. Making sure that the information about notable women in science is of the highest quality is one way to celebrate their accomplishments. It would be really good if someone is able to add the lady scientists who received this lifetime achievement award.
Thanks,
GerardM
Thursday, November 28, 2013
A #brilliant idea barnstar
User:West.andrew.g provides really neat information about the English #Wikipedia. He shows the "popular redlinks".
Thanks,
GerardM
This is a weekly list of the most requested red links on Wikipedia. It was developed as a corollary of the Top 5000. While this list contains many non-human views, this list can help identify notable topics and search requests that should be created or redirected. This list displays redlinks that have 1000+ views in the prior week interval (run on Sunday mornings, UTC locale).Information like this is so valuable; it shows what people are looking for and cannot find. It is highly likely that adding information about these subjects will result in many more page views. As a Wikipedia becomes better able to provide information, it will at some stage reach the tipping point where it is really useful. For many Wikipedias this is still a goal we are aiming for,
Thanks,
GerardM
Wednesday, November 27, 2013
An #encyclopaedia in #Konkani
The #Wikimedia blog announced that the Vishwakosh was re-released under a free license. This is really welcome news for Konkani speakers and, it allows for the inclusion of the 3632 pages in a Konkani Wikipedia.
When the Vishwakosh is to stay in its current format, it is no Wikipedia but a Wikisource. Given the text in the blog, they want a Wikipedia and by definition the texts will change. There will be updates that reflect more recent developments.
But first the Wikipedia has to be released from the Incubator. With so much involvement of so many people, it must be easy to have all the localisations done in next to no time.
The language committee can expedite it when there is movement in this direction.
Thanks,
GerardM
When the Vishwakosh is to stay in its current format, it is no Wikipedia but a Wikisource. Given the text in the blog, they want a Wikipedia and by definition the texts will change. There will be updates that reflect more recent developments.
But first the Wikipedia has to be released from the Incubator. With so much involvement of so many people, it must be easy to have all the localisations done in next to no time.
The language committee can expedite it when there is movement in this direction.
Thanks,
GerardM
Tuesday, November 26, 2013
Fixing #Wikidata labels using a concept cloud
The new "concept cloud" is great; you may have read about it elsewhere and as I know about it for some time, I have been using it a lot lately. It is ever so addictive.
It is probably the most obvious way to make sure that information can be found on a subject and all the subjects that surround it. Contrary to Wikipedia where it is wise to stay clear of subjects that are dear to you, there is nothing stopping you from making sure that information on your subject is well established.
Here are the things I have learned so far:
It is probably the most obvious way to make sure that information can be found on a subject and all the subjects that surround it. Contrary to Wikipedia where it is wise to stay clear of subjects that are dear to you, there is nothing stopping you from making sure that information on your subject is well established.
Here are the things I have learned so far:
- the spelling of a lot of labels need improvement.. things are not capitalised
- many items have little or no statements
- refreshing a concept cloud gives a sense of accomplishment
- many items have no labels in a language I know.
- Please help with Korean, Farsi, Arabic and add English
There is "method to the madness"; as more items gain labels in your language, it becomes more important to utilise this information in search requests. Particularly for the smaller languages this is the only feasible way to get to the tipping point quickly where we provide a reasonable service.
Thanks,
GerardM
Sunday, November 24, 2013
#Wikidata HOWTO - #Commons categories
To realise this is actually something quite relevant. Consider the example of Q726 or horse for instance. "Horse" is known in 178 languages and consequently there is already a word for it in these 178 languages. To find it in even more languages someone just has to add the right label.
It works by linking Q726 to the Commons category "Equus ferus caballus". It is the item for the concept itself that needs to connects to the Commons category, not other categories nor lists nor whatever.
The Commons category provides you hopefully with loads of images and while everything that is written on that page may be unintelligible it gets you more horsies. When you are adventurous you will find that Q146 gets you kitty cats and Q144 will get you doggies...
Thanks,
GerardM
Friday, November 22, 2013
More of that heady stuff
The blogpost about the "heady stuff of Wikidata" proved interesting. Many people read it and recently there was a lengthy reaction from Mike Bergman. It is quite interesting because he indicates that the work he does may be used for Wikipedia and Wikidata as well.
So have a read of what Mike had to say. <grin> Maybe there will be a follow up </grin> ...
Thanks,
GerardM
Hi Gerard,
Sorry my comments on this are coming in a bit late; I only recently stumbled upon your thoughtful post.
For some time, as one of the editors of UMBEL, I have been convinced that much could be done to improve the category structure of Wikipedia. In fact, our most recent formal release of UMBEL has mappings to about half of the content of Wikipedia, most done by hand or using heuristics. Our hope in doing this work is to provide consistent organization, faceting, inference and semantic search over Wikipedia's contents. The extension into Wikidata is only raising the importance of a tractable upper structure.
Though there are literally hundreds of hours in our effort to date, it is not easily repeatable nor scalable. Further, there are many of the longer-tail concepts in Wikipedia for which heuristics and manual approaches simply are not appropriate.
Our efforts in this area have led us to look at many alternative mapping approaches, many of which we have tried ourselves and tested internally.
The best that we encountered that moved in the right direction was Aleksander Pohl's work with OpenCyc and Wikipedia. After about a year of discussions, we have just reached a formal agreement with Aleksander and his team to extend his prior efforts, only focusing on UMBEL as the mapping target this time. (Though the same new approaches may again be extended to OpenCyc.)
The market will likely tell us if small structures (as you cite), medium structures (such as the 28 K concepts in UMBEL), larger structures (the 300K or so in OpenCyc), or other structures (such as SUMO or whatever), will best fit the bill of better organizing Wikipedia content and making it tractable. We are committed to placing our approach into the public domain soon.
We should have some results to share on our UMBEL-Wikipedia mappings shortly (weeks, not months). We will do what we can to announce this availability, and we look forward to your and the community's comments and response to this effort. We think we will have a winning approach, but only the market will tell!
Good luck on your own efforts, and let me know if we can be of any assistance.
Best, Mike
#Wikimaps loves #Wikidata
Wikidata has potential. That much is clear. What is not so clear is when a tipping point is reached for a new use of its data.
The image to the right is that it is from a presentation by Susanna Ånäs about the "Wikimedia Old Map project". In it Wikidata is already very well connected. It makes sense because it may include maps and by using qualifiers it can be obvious when that map was drawn. Wikidata is also where you can add old names for everything that is on the map. Last but not least, Wikidata has always been able to include names in other languages.
Thanks,
GerardM
The image to the right is that it is from a presentation by Susanna Ånäs about the "Wikimedia Old Map project". In it Wikidata is already very well connected. It makes sense because it may include maps and by using qualifiers it can be obvious when that map was drawn. Wikidata is also where you can add old names for everything that is on the map. Last but not least, Wikidata has always been able to include names in other languages.
Thanks,
GerardM
Wednesday, November 20, 2013
#Wikidata & #Freebase - an #interview with Denny Vrandečić
When Denny signalled the availability of data that links Wikidata to Freebase, there was a lot of follow up and several questions were left unanswered. So I asked my questions and, I am happy with the answers I received. So enjoy this interview about the Wikidata and Freebase connection.
Thanks,
GerardM
By moving to California you embrace yet another culture, language.What does it do to you, your family
Thanks,
GerardM
By moving to California you embrace yet another culture, language.What does it do to you, your family
My wife is from Uzbekistan, I am from Croatia. We met in Israel. She has lived the last few years in Estonia, I in Germany. We have moved to California, and we are very excited about this move. Finally to live in a country where we both speak the language! And also, we have high hopes with regards to the weather.
The US in general, and San Francisco in particular, is a real melting pot - or rather fruit salad, as they say these days - of people from all over the world. This seems to be a good match to our own background, so we are looking forward to see what this will mean for us.
What is your job description and title at Google (and what is it you actually do)
My job title is "Ontologist". I am working on Google's Knowledge Graph. The Knowledge Graph for Google is basically what Wikidata is for the Wikimedia projects: a repository of structured knowledge about the world, that is used in many different ways in various different applications. I am working, together with a great team, on the schema and ontology of the Knowledge Graph: its data model, schema, and the way it captures and represents knowledge.
What is Freebase and how does it compare with Wikidata
Freebase is the publicly available and editable part of the Knowledge Graph. Freebase and Wikidata are very similar. At the same time, there are quite a few differences: the user communities, the incentive architecture, the license, the way sources and knowledge diversity are handled, to name the big differences. There are also minor differences in the data model, the way classes, properties, types interact with each other, the UI, the workflows, the prominence of internationalization, currently also the size and scope of the knowledge bases, etc. Wikidata currently has 22 Million statements, Freebase has 2 Billion facts. Now one should always be careful with such simple metrics, and especially these numbers are not comparable, but it hints at some differences in the knowledge base.
Do you work on FB or is this only an outward facing project
Freebase is a part of the Knowledge Graph, and I work on the Knowledge Graph, so yeah, I also work on Freebase.
With a link between FB and WD it will be possible data can flow from WD because of its license. How is it for a flow from the other direction
I am not a lawyer, but unfortunately it seems that the licenses used by Freebase and Wikidata would not allow for that direction. We are aware that this is not good, and we are working on ways to fix this.
But even without actually letting data flow from Freebase to Wikidata, such an alignment can be valuable for the Wikidata editors: bots could compare the data, and flag inconsistencies. Bots could do simple comparisons, like, go through all the countries, compare the capitals, and report on the differences. And this can be done not only with Freebase, but with any other structured or semi-structured base that Wikidata connects to. One example is the work that Maximilian Klein did, comparing the sex/gender of authors connected through the VIAF ID.
The data for the FB<->WD connection is based on a WD dump, How will it be maintained in the future
This is not decided yet. In principle, we could create this dump regularly, but I am unsure if this will be needed. We will have to see how things develop before deciding on what to do next.
When info exist in both WD and FB and it differs, what would you like to see done
The difference to be fixed, obviously! Both knowledge bases may and do contain errors, and the ability to compare them can lead to an increased quality level in both. It is obvious that the respective communities should take care of such errors in their knowledge bases. By providing links between the knowledge bases, this should get easier to automate.
Would that be a model for collaboration with other sources like VIAF
Yes, in many cases that should work. It is clear that some sources and their communities are more open to corrections than others. Wikidata can become a central hub for identity on the Web, collecting and reconciling IDs from many different sources. What makes Wikidata so interesting in itself is its commitment to let everyone share in the sum of all knowledge - both in participating in creating it as well as in accessing it. The barriers are so much lower than almost anywhere else. In which other knowledge base can you easily fix an error?
Does FB have sources for its statements
Yes, but this is quite a different notion from what Wikidata does with sources. When a dataset is being uploaded to Freebase, the source for this upload is usually recorded. It is closer to what is usually called "provenance", whereas Wikidata's notion of a source is closer to what is called a "reference", an external authority that makes the given claim. A strength of Wikidata is the diversity of the sources, and that they can be refined later by the community. A statement in Wikidata can have several sources (which makes sense if you think of them as references supporting the statement), but in Freebase every statement only has one source (which again makes sense if you think about it being the provenance of that statement, from where this statement came from).
(I don't understand the question, and rephrase it to: do you prefer an unsourced statement over no statement?)
In most cases, yes, I'd rather have an unsourced statement than no statement at all. In a perfect world, all statements in Wikidata would have great, authoritative sources. But for now, I really think that Wikidata should be lenient with regards to unsourced statements in most cases. There are obvious cases where this is not true: data about living persons has to be more carefully sourced, especially when it has the opportunity to hurt the person. Also, we have to remember, that a Wikipedia community can decide to use a statement from Wikidata only if it is sourced, and to drop it otherwise. Once Wikidata has matured a bit, I expect it to move towards a more stricter policy, and to see tools develop that help with getting there. That will be a quite exciting time.
What FB feature would you LOVE to have in Wikidata
The expressive query features of Freebase. The Wikidata team is hard on working towards enabling this, and I am very much looking forward to see it happen: this will open a whole new world of possibilities for everyone using Wikidata's data, and it will lead to much more visibility of the data and help to refine the Wikidata properties.
Tuesday, November 19, 2013
#Wikidata HOWTO - Some properties are best used as a qualifier
Some Wikidata properties are practically by definition qualifiers. Consider time for instance, there is the "point in time", the "start date", the "end date" and all of them are in relation to something else. For instance when a Noble prize was awarded, when a King ascended to a throne and when for whatever reason he was no longer the ruler ... "Le roi est mort. Vive le roi !!".
Working on Wikidata items is very much a learning process. As you go, you learn and come to conclusions. For me it is now obvious; properties about time and dates are qualifiers.. always.
Thanks,
GerardM
Working on Wikidata items is very much a learning process. As you go, you learn and come to conclusions. For me it is now obvious; properties about time and dates are qualifiers.. always.
Thanks,
GerardM
Sign language in #Tunisia can have a #Wikipedia too
On #Facebook I noticed what looked like an encyclopaedic article. It was about the poet Aboul-Qacem Echebbi.
When asked, they were interested in having a Wikipedia. Once a request has been made on Meta, the procedure to determine eligibility will start. In this case it is a formality as both native "speakers" and an ISO 639-3 code are present.
Once this procedure has been completed, it will be permitted to edit Wikidata as well.
In the Language Committee a discussion has started to consider if the completion of a set number of fully labelled items can be accepted as part of fulfilling the current requirement of the 200 Wikipedia articles. Reducing this number to 50 will make it more easy to complete the writing requirement. Currently many of these articles are not much more than sub-stubs.
Thanks,
GerardM
When asked, they were interested in having a Wikipedia. Once a request has been made on Meta, the procedure to determine eligibility will start. In this case it is a formality as both native "speakers" and an ISO 639-3 code are present.
Once this procedure has been completed, it will be permitted to edit Wikidata as well.
In the Language Committee a discussion has started to consider if the completion of a set number of fully labelled items can be accepted as part of fulfilling the current requirement of the 200 Wikipedia articles. Reducing this number to 50 will make it more easy to complete the writing requirement. Currently many of these articles are not much more than sub-stubs.
Thanks,
GerardM
The Case for Localizing Names, "part 3"
My friend Amir wrote twice ([1], [2]) about the need for the localisation of names. The need for localisation is rather obvious when the original name is in another script. But names written in the Latin script can be as foreign. Take for instance the Czech author and screenwriter Jiří Růžička, I do not know how to type his name and, I am sure 98% of the users of Wikidata will be able to do so either.
When a name uses characters that are not in use in a language, it follows that the name is unlikely to be found in a language and consequently transliteration is in order. The name as originally written is not an alias. It is something different. It probably needs an attribute of the type "multilingual text" for support in Wikidata.
Thanks,
GerardM
When a name uses characters that are not in use in a language, it follows that the name is unlikely to be found in a language and consequently transliteration is in order. The name as originally written is not an alias. It is something different. It probably needs an attribute of the type "multilingual text" for support in Wikidata.
Thanks,
GerardM
Monday, November 18, 2013
#Ask and it will be #given to you II
Sharing in the sum of all knowledge is the aim of the #Wikimedia Foundation. The challenge is to bring it to all people of this world. Given that its projects are Internet based, it is reasonable to concentrate on the people connected to the Internet.
With one extra line in the USER/common,js it is possible to expand the search by adding results from Wikidata. This has been mentioned before.
What is new is, that it will now include references to articles in Wikipedia and pictures in Commons. Just click on the Commons logo and you go to the Commons category for the subject when it is known in Wikidata. When you click on the Wikipedia logo, you get a box with the Wikis you can choose from.
Really cool is that the Reasonator will provide you information in YOUR language. It is probably the best incentive to add the labels missing for your language. Remember, labels are used everywhere.
Talking about Reasonator, we are looking for a nice logo that we can use...
Thanks,
GerardM
With one extra line in the USER/common,js it is possible to expand the search by adding results from Wikidata. This has been mentioned before.
What is new is, that it will now include references to articles in Wikipedia and pictures in Commons. Just click on the Commons logo and you go to the Commons category for the subject when it is known in Wikidata. When you click on the Wikipedia logo, you get a box with the Wikis you can choose from.
Really cool is that the Reasonator will provide you information in YOUR language. It is probably the best incentive to add the labels missing for your language. Remember, labels are used everywhere.
Talking about Reasonator, we are looking for a nice logo that we can use...
Thanks,
GerardM
#Ask and it will be #given to you
Reading about Ask 1.0 is like getting the sensation of falling through a rabbit hole and ending up in Wonderland. You read that it is the query language that is already used by Semantic MediaWiki, it allows for the creation of lists of any item in a Wikipedia article.
Semantic MediaWiki was great but this, this allows for the use of Wikidata !! It is written by the developers of Wikidata!!
Please can we have it... like yesterday ???
PLEASE
Thanks,
Alice
Semantic MediaWiki was great but this, this allows for the use of Wikidata !! It is written by the developers of Wikidata!!
Please can we have it... like yesterday ???
PLEASE
Thanks,
Alice
Sunday, November 17, 2013
#Wikimedia #HOWTO - Supporting dyslexic people
One small detail that deserves much more attention is the ability to support people who are dyslectic. This support is thanks to a wonderful little project called OpenDyslexic. It is a font that is designed in such a way that most persons with dyslexia find it a lot easier to read.
There are several reasons why our support for dyslectic people deserves more attention;
The CEE conference in Modra was really constructive; so many subjects were discussed including OpenDyslexic. The bug to enable OpenDyslexic for Polish, indicates that many of the things discussed are actionable and are being acted upon.
Thanks,
GerardM
There are several reasons why our support for dyslectic people deserves more attention;
- seven percent of a population is dyslectic
- people who have found how to enable this font are happy
- we do not know how many people use OpenDyslexic
- we are told that people find it hard to enable the font
- OpenDyslexic could be used for languages like Polish
- some languages cannot use OpenDyslexic because characters are not supported
The CEE conference in Modra was really constructive; so many subjects were discussed including OpenDyslexic. The bug to enable OpenDyslexic for Polish, indicates that many of the things discussed are actionable and are being acted upon.
Thanks,
GerardM
The #Wikidata workshop
At the #CEE meeting in #Modra, it was a pleasure to inform about the latest about Wikidata. At the conference the idea of a workshop was launched. The question posed was: "show us what is already there, show us what we can already do".
There is a lot to show. There is the progress that is made by the development team, there are the many tools created by Magnus and, there are the templates used on several Wikipedias. People are impressed but for many purposes it is not good enough. This is understandable, Wikidata is not feature complete. Many things we want to do are under development.
If there is one thing I wanted to achieve is that people understand that while Wikidata is incomplete, it is already functional. There are great tools that emulate what people are looking for. There are things that do make a difference today .. Tipping points have been reached for several uses and as more people make use of Wikidata and include the data that is relevant to them, more tipping points will be reached.
Thanks,
GerardM
If there is one thing I wanted to achieve is that people understand that while Wikidata is incomplete, it is already functional. There are great tools that emulate what people are looking for. There are things that do make a difference today .. Tipping points have been reached for several uses and as more people make use of Wikidata and include the data that is relevant to them, more tipping points will be reached.
Thanks,
GerardM
Friday, November 15, 2013
#Wikidata HOWTO - Lists are evil
Ivan Gašparovič is the current president of #Slovakia. During a demonstration of Wikidata in Slovakia, it became clear that he was linked for the office he holds to "list of presidents of Slovakia". This was considered to be wrong as there is an article and therefore an item for the "president of Slovakia".
It did not long to fix this and fix this for the former presidents of Slovakia as well. So now the labels associated with the list is wrong in many languages and, there is no label in languages like French and German for the office Mr Gašparovič is holding.
All in all, many Wikipedias refer to lists. In Wikidata this does not really work.
Thanks,
GerardM
It did not long to fix this and fix this for the former presidents of Slovakia as well. So now the labels associated with the list is wrong in many languages and, there is no label in languages like French and German for the office Mr Gašparovič is holding.
All in all, many Wikipedias refer to lists. In Wikidata this does not really work.
Thanks,
GerardM
Thursday, November 14, 2013
#Wikidata HOWTO - micro tasks
When you have some spare time, there is always something that does not take long to do. The main page of the English Wikipedia mentioned the scientist Michael E. Brown. In 2012 he was awarded the Kavli prize for astrophysics. It does not take much time to make a statement about this prize on the "item" for Mr Brown and on the the items for the other recipients as well.
Yes, many of them received other prizes, but that is another job well worth doing.
Thanks,
GerardM
Yes, many of them received other prizes, but that is another job well worth doing.
Thanks,
GerardM
#Wikidata HOWTO - generated descriptions
#Disambiguation in Wikidata is typically done based on the descriptions of items. Most items do not have descriptions so it is typically a struggle to select the right items. Enter a nice little hack by Magnus called "autodesc"; it automagically creates descriptions on the fly based on existing statements.
It is one of the most valuable hacks I know off. All it takes to activate it is adding this one line to your common.js page.
It is one of the most valuable hacks I know off. All it takes to activate it is adding this one line to your common.js page.
- mw.loader.load('//tools.wmflabs.org/wikidata-todo/autodesc.js');
Many hardcore Wikidatians do not yet know about this little tool. Once they find out how useful this is, they will not go back to adding descriptions but they will add the missing statements that identify the items in any language. Like me they will consider this an obvious improvement in the Wikidata user experience.
Thanks,
GerardM
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






















