It is said that the community is always right. It also has a short term memory and its consensus is not necessarily what you hope for.
Take Mr Sanders, he died recently and it was indicated that he was a "List of Governors of Georgia". It is an old argument that is the result of some bad practice at Wikipedia. The Wikipedia article includes mainly a list and consequently it is to be called a list. There is no article about the subject itself and hey "it must be a list in Wikidata as well".
It is simple to fix the situation for the governor of Georgia. All articles are lists, there is no Wikipedia that has both a list article and an article so I had the item identify the subject.
Using the category I added many of the "missing" governors, there were only 15 humans known to be governor of Georgia. I made all of them a politician and an US-American.
The community has every right to rehash old arguments. I just follow the old consensus and wait for the dust to settle yet again.
Thanks,
GerardM
No comments:
Post a Comment