Showing posts with label categories. Show all posts
Showing posts with label categories. Show all posts

Sunday, April 23, 2023

Analysis of a Wikipedia article

For professor Gerhard Gries there is a Wikipedia article and as a consequence there was a Wikidata item. Actually there were two; they have been merged. Many articles have been attributed to professor Gries and a Scholia template was added to the article.

Professor Gries has his own lab: the "Gerhard and Regine Gries Lab". There is no article for his wife and, there was no red link. There was no Wikidata item for his wife but there were 59 links indicating her as a missing co-author. She has now 68 articles linked to her as an author or co-author. Regine Gries is now a "woman in red".

The article states in two places that he is a "Fellow of the Entomological Society of America" (2019). It is in the text and it is in a Wikipedia category. Relevant are two additional lists; the website of the Entomological Society of America and the result of a query at Wikidata (shown in a Scholia). All these lists are incomplete, the fellows of 2022 are not yet included on the SoA website; they can be found in a different place. The Scholia has been added to the category article on the English Wikipedia; in effect you will find several "fellows in red". 

Three additional awards are listed, awards that have no category on the article. One is for the "Fellow of the Entomological Society of Canada", its reference may be found here. Another one is for the Nan-Yao Su Award and finally the Gold Medal of the Entomological Society of Canada had to be added to Wikidata. There are always more "award winners in red" to be found or to be added.

Every list, every category in Wikipedia is likely to be incomplete. What we do not know may be relevant. With data on missing articles available in Wikidata, there are more more options to make Wikipedia more inclusive.

Thanks,
       GerardM

Saturday, August 29, 2020

Proposal for the liberal use of data from the Wikipedias and Wikidata

Every Wikimedia project has information available that could be shared with other Wikimedia projects. Data is incomplete in every project and the objective of this proposal is to indicate missing data so that it may be included.

It starts with a category. This category links to six English Wikipedia articles. Using a tool, that information is now available in Wikidata as well. As this information is further enriched, it is found that one article should be included in the category.

The category exists on many Wikipedias, in the defintion of the category it is known what content the category contains in Wikidata. Reasonator shows the information with an inbuilt query. When you check the article with a list, it is obvious that many articles do not have a category entry. The latest entry in the list is known to Wikidata thanks to the Latin Wikipedia..

The proposal is simple. Have a messaging agent that indicates missing categories on articles. This will enable any Wikipedian to add them. For Wikidata we would import data based on the definition of categories. The process would be enabled per defined category.

Arguments: 
  • Nothing happens on a Wikipedia without prior agreement
  • The mechanism used is by default one of signalling and not of updating 
  • It follows existing practice for importing data from Wikipedias into Wikidata
Thanks,
      GerardM

Tuesday, October 24, 2017

#Wikipedia - Student or Athlete or both ?

College football, soccer, basketball, whatever is a USA phenomenon where young people attent a college or a university on a sports scholarship.

Wikipedia has categories for the different sports and members of such teams are these categories are typically a subcategory for the alumni of a college or university.

For Wikidata the alumni are typically harvested from the specific alumni catalogs and as a consequence it is as if all the athletes did not have an education.

My question, how can we best associate these college/university categories with the alumni categories?
Thanks,
      GerardM

Monday, May 22, 2017

#Wikidata - One size fits all but only size 47 serves me well

When a Wikipedia decides on its policies; in the end it is a "one size fits all". It is the policy wonks who decide and all editors have to abide by it and all readers suffer the consequences. Shoes are made for walking but you only get the best mileage out of shoes when they fit.

When you look at the categories for different Wikipedias they are not the same. Some explicitly exclude the standard information of other Wikipedias. As a result there is no universal standard and this is detrimental to readers who frequent multiple Wikipedias.

At the same time, a Wikipedia community may define its policies and practices as they see fit. This does not mean that they define what individual readers actually prefer only what they get presented. The amount of categories in use and their structure is a good example how editors define information given or withheld from readers. Increasingly the combined information from categories from Wikipedias find their way into Wikidata. When a Wikipedia does not include a category, by using the definitions for a category it is possible to present many if not most of what a category could have been.

The question is not can we show what articles of a Wikipedia would be in a category, the question is if our readers will be supported and if not what arguments we have to disallow readers the structures they personally prefer.
Thanks,
      GerardM


Sunday, March 12, 2017

#Wikidata - Maren Hassinger is on the "Black Lunch Table"

Maren Hassinger is a sculptor born in Los Angeles. She was awarded both the Anonymous Was A Woman Award and the Women's Caucus for Art Lifetime Achievement Award. In addition to this there is a Wikipedia article.

When you read the article, all kinds of statements are made that could reflect in the article having Wikipedia categories. In this case statements in Wikidata were made.

The outward appearance is that Wikipedia and Wikidata are two distinct projects. Wikidata however has always included data from Wikipedia and there has always been a realisation that Wikipedia in its turn could benefit from Wikidata; generating category entries should be possible for instance.

When you consider the immediate future of the Wikimedia projects, Commons will be wikidatified. One part of the information that is directly related to GLAM activities is registering the museums that include an artist in their collection. This is applicable for many artists that are part of the Black Lunch Table including Mrs Hassinger. So the question is; should we include such information in Wikidata and how should we do this?
Thanks,
      GerardM

Thursday, March 12, 2015

#Wikidata - #Diversity and #LGBT

Richard Glatzer died. He died from motor neurone disease. I added this for everyone who died in this way. Mr Glatzer is associated through four categories with LGBT and I will not touch any of these with a bargepole.

I will not touch it because it is so redundant and opaque. When people are associated with LGBT, I do not know they are gay and in what way. What I care for is that sexual orientation is expressed in Wikidata once.

Associating people with LGBT does not mean that people who are gay have been active and known as such. It does not even mean that the people who are championing the cause of LGBT are gay.

From my position, the information about LGBT sucks big time, I can not use it and, I find this regrettable.
Thanks,
     GerardM



Tuesday, December 30, 2014

#Wikipedia - She did not study at #Washburn #University

I like this picture. It is all I like about this person who according to the article about her studied at Washburn University. According to the article about the Washburn University school of law, she is a "notable alumni".

The issue is that there is no category for these alumni yet. It is something the Wikipedia editors did not do. So I want to borrow one of the slogans from the picture..
Mourn your sins
The others fit the person in the picture more than anything else. It is certainly colourful.
Thanks,
      Gerard

Monday, December 29, 2014

#Wikidata - 2000 #categories with a #list

When people die and it becomes known in Wikipedia, often more can be said about that person than just his date of death. They may have studied, held an office, been a member of a sports team or a political party. Much of this information is registered in categories.

Thanks to Autolist2 it is easy to add all that information to Wikidata. The best bit is that we can indicate what conditions the articles in the category have to fulfill in Wikidata itself. It is picked up by the Reasonator and this shows in these 2000 categories that have had the treatment so far.

So check out these categories, click on the Reasonator icon and be amazed about the number of items that have been enriched slowly but surely.
Thanks,
      GerardM

PS You can do this as well :)

Saturday, December 06, 2014

#Wikidata - #Bangladesh #University of #Engineering and Technology

The Bangladesh University of Engineering and Technology currently knows 16 people who studied there. Two of them were in a category that had not yet been created.  In theory 16 articles are waiting for them to be added to this category. In addition, someone may want to categorise the category..

The good news in all this:
  • Wikidata can be used to populate Wikipedia categories
  • people are actively adding information in Wikidata first
  • by adding students and faculty in Wikidata, people are connected and consequently the universities and colleges get exposure
  • Maybe, my call to the college boys and girls is heard by some of them
Thanks,
      GerardM

Sunday, November 02, 2014

#Wikidata - #Wikipedia categories

Wikidata knows about Wikipedia categories. Currently there are items for 2,406,128 categories. Many of those items refer to categories in multiple Wikipedias. One random example is item Q8884100, it refers to categories in 10 Wikipedias. All of them categorize people who studied at the university of Notre Dame. Many of them know about people only known in that Wikipedia. In addition to this there may be articles that are not categorised or references to articles that are not in one of the 10 categories known at this time.
When multiple categorised are "harvested" in Wikidata, Wikidata knows about more items than any of the individual categories. This enables the use of the data in new ways.
  • suggest categories based on the presence of statements in the Wikidata category
  • suggest statement when an article is included in a category
  • include red links in a category when a Wikipedia does not have articles.
Before such functionality will become available, certain tipping points will need to be reached. For instance enough categories need to be harvested in this way and, these categories have to be identifiable for the information they include.

The category "University of Notre Dame alumni" indicates that it is a list of humans AND, for them the statement "alma mater" "University of Notre Dame" has to be made. For over 1450 categories that are about humans similar information exists. Every day more categories are added.

I really wonder what it takes to reach the tipping points that will bring more application of the Wikidata data to for instance Wikipedia.
Thanks,
     GerardM

Thursday, October 23, 2014

#Wikipedia - One size does not fit all


In Wikipedia we are used to see our readers as one big group. They all read the same article, they all get the same info-boxes and they all get the same categories. It is a reasonable approach when Wikipedia is only a pile of text without data to separate out potential differences in interest.

One obvious consequence is that reasonable expectations decide what is shown and what it looks like. When there are too many categories, they no longer get attention. So what categories should be shown? The problem is that this "one size fits all" approach shows too much for some and too little for others.

Thanks to Wikidata it is possible to allow for preferences. For many categories Wikidata knows what they are about; they show for instance humans and their alma mater, their sports club, their gender... When our public has the option to choose what category of category they are interested in, there is no longer a "need" to choose what categories to keep. It is just a matter of making the choice what categories to show by default.

Any and all other category of categories are then selectable by the reader.
Thanks,
      GerardM

Tuesday, September 30, 2014

#Wikipedia - #Category: #Cholmondeley Awards

A poet is proverbially poor. If there are any, it is not really an occupation but more of an aspiration to live off the high art of poetry. To celebrate great authors, great poets, organisations like the Society of Authors, recognise them with awards. Money may be involved, but the prestige, the awareness of the public is what makes the real difference for a poet.

The Cholondeley Award is to "honour distinguished poets" and, yes there is some money to be had; £8000 to be exact. There is still a category for the distinguished ladies and gentlemen who were awarded in the past. It is up for deletion because £8000 is considered chicken feed and also because awards are supposed to be in a list, not a category per WP:OC#AWARD.

It was a revelation for me that there is something like "over categorisation" in the first place. It means that categories are deleted. Wikipedia is a law unto itself and given "consensus", categories will be deleted. It is sad that all the work that went into the categorisation is deleted with those categories. It is even worse when the implied information is not first saved to Wikidata.

Categories distinguish themselves from lists because they can be found on every article that is categorised. Changes to article names are automatically reflected while Wikipedia lists are ... static. In Wikidata, lists can be defined up to a point and funnily enough this is not done for lists but it is done for categories.
The information from the category has been saved with AutoList2. Given that Wikidata often knows about more recipients of awards than any and all Wikipedias individually, the current emphasis on lists is silly. Wikidata will do a better job.
Thanks,
      GerardM

Wednesday, August 27, 2014

#Wikipedia - Professor Hermann Buhl "Leichtathlet"

Mr Buhl died in Tirol wandering through the Alps.  He used to be an athlete of repute and became a professor at the Julius Maximilians-Universiteit.

It is obvious that Mr Buhl was a professor because of his presence in a category. It is not obvious in the same way where he studied and what he taught. When you read the text, it expects a lot of knowledge about the DDR for the text to make such things obvious.

Every Wikipedia has its notability criteria and, the German Wikipedia is not different. Mr Buhl is certainly notable as an athlete but his career did not end. He is probable notable as well for the "latter" part of his career. Some would argue that he started to contribute in a meaningful way when he taught in university.
Thanks,
      GerardM

Sunday, August 17, 2014

#Wikidata - giving a #category an application

Many #Wikimedia categories have interlanguage links. Obviously the content of all these linked categories do not have the same content. Someone has to add the articles, sometimes it gets done and sometimes it doesn't. Often articles just do not exist.

When the facts that are implicit in what a category is about make it to all the items in all the categories, typically you have a superset in Wikidata. It does not stop there; items in Wikidata may be included that are not in any of those linked categories.

This is all theoretical unless ... unless you can query Wikidata and use the results. Much data has been added to Wikidata based on the content of categories and queries have been used to identify missing items this is done using AutoList2. This is one application; it is used by some of the "advanced" users of Wikidata.

What is even more interesting is showing what Wikidata things should be in a category. This is done using Reasonator. At this time for over 690 categories statements are included that define a query. This query is already complex enough that the Wikidata functionality will not be able to express the results..

These queries could be of use to "advanced" Wikipedians because it is a basis for identifying articles that have not been categorised or articles that still need to be written in their Wikipedia. For everyone else it is just interesting; this information exists and it is readily available. It is one way of learning that Wikidata knows for instance about 121,922 politicians.
Thanks,
      GerardM

Saturday, August 02, 2014

#Wikidata - is the 60th Infantry Division (Wehrmacht) a "division"

It seems obvious; the 60th Infantry Division (Wehrmacht) is an "infantry division" and, it is part of the Wehrmacht. There are a few problems though
  • the logo has it that it is the "60th motorised division"
  • Wikidata does not know "infantry division"
  • The German Wikipedia has a category of all infantry divisions of the Wehrmacht
  • The Waffen SS is considered to be a division of the Wehrmacht in Wikidata
It is fairly easy to include all the divisions that are in the German category as divisions and as being part of the Wehrmacht. It is fairly easy to create an item for "infantry division" as well and use that in stead of "division". Or have a "motorised division"..

It is all too easy to have other people become angry when you decide one way or the other. They are the splitters and the lumpers. The worst thing is that all communication is only happening in writing and often quite angrily. Communication on IRC is dysfunctional and this is considered a failure of the community because they could use one channel that is dominated by discussions about Wikidata development. 

Never mind, you cannot win maybe play even.
Thanks,
     GerardM


Wednesday, April 30, 2014

#Wikipedia - the case for and against #categories

Wikipedia categories are lists maintained by people by adding a line at the end of an article one at a time. Categories can be part of categories and therefore you can have one for Paleontologists and one for Women paleontologists. In order to be a female paleontologist, you have to be in both categories..

Wikidata knows about categories, females and paleontologists. With Reasonator you will find information about all three including what Wikidata expects to find in the category of Paleontologists and Women paleontologists. The number of entries are not the same; a human with an occupation of paleontologist who is female will make it into the list presented by the Reasonator.

The case for categories is a simple one. It is the place where we harvest data from for Wikidata. Until we have something better, it is the place where we will have to come back to.
Thanks,
      GerardM

Tuesday, March 18, 2014

#Wikidata - the replication to #Labs works again

The #Reasonator uses Wikidata data and to make sure that its data is always close to "up to date", a replication processupdates Reasonator every 10 minutes or so. To do this, it needs a Wikidata dump and, incremental backups are really nice to have. Once the latest available back ups are included, replication will pick the later changes up and, the result can be something like all the members of the Lok Sahha.

The Lok Sabha is the lower chamber of parliament in India. Reasonator showss the first 500 members known in Wikidata and, the rest you can see using AutoList.

Saturday there is a edit-a-thon in India. They will write about the female members of the Lok Sabha. We can make a query for this as well. As labels in the languages of India are added to Wikidata, these parliamentarians will be found when you search for them because all the Wikipedias of India make use of Wikidata extended search.

In this way, we make another step in sharing in the sum of all knowledge.
Thanks,
       GerardM


Sunday, February 23, 2014

#Wikipedia categories are #lists and an #ontology in a way.

When you look at Wikipedia categories, they refer to articles that fit certain criteria. What you may also find other more specialised categories and "meta articles".

Take for instance the category "Painters by Nationality". You will expect that all articles about people; they are "human" and they are all painters. The category "Indian painters" includes painters who have the Indian nationality. It has a subcategory "Indian woman painters" they have the female gender.

When people want to know their names in Hindi, Gujarati or Telugu, they can find them and even add the missing ones.

By implication, suggestions for Wikidata statements can be made when articles are added to categories. They are what defines the "list" in Wikidata. Suggestions can be ignored but the consequence is that Wikidata will not know them as belonging in that category.

Suggesting what categories articles belong to is much harder. However, when an article on the same subject exists in another language, categories that are shared between the languages are obvious targets.

All this hinges on a shared understanding of what categories are.
Thanks,
      GerardM

Tuesday, December 31, 2013

English #Wikipedia uses #Wikidata data

One of the tipping points for Wikidata usage is when the English Wikipedia starts using its data. It has. There is even a category for templates that use Wikidata data. This category is linked to Wikidata as well and there are more Wikipedias that have a similar category.

This list is obviously not complete; the Occitan Wikipedia for instance is not included.

It is exciting to learn about this at the very end of 2013. Next year will be even better.
Thanks,
     GerardM

Sunday, December 29, 2013

#Wikidata - how many ontologies do we need?

When you check out items in Wikidata, chances are that they have links to one or more external resources. The picture to the right shows how DBpedia is connected to even more external resources. As you may know, DBpedia and Wikidata also have a very tight connection.

In a way, this can be compared to the many connections Wikidata has to the categories in the many Wikipedias, in Commons. All of them have structure of some kind. Information is inferred and acted upon. The category "United States Army Medal of Honor recipients" refers to people who received the Medal of honor.

When Wikidata is linked to external sources, these links have to be there for a reason. It can be to compare information or it can be to add missing information either way. Applications based on the ontology structure of the external sources can apply their logic on Wikidata.

Yes, there may be a purpose for yet another ontology structure in Wikidata. It may allow for implied information in tools native to Wikidata. But there is no point to all of them when we do not make use of them.
Thanks,
     GerardM